Authors: - A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P R S T V W X Y Z

Reviews For Harry Potter and the Caliban Poltergeist by MudbloodMatt

Stormdelver
Friday 11th November 2005 13:09
Harry Potter and the Caliban Poltergeist
Good build-up, paints a nice picture of gothic dread
LoonyPhoenix
Sunday 31st October 2004 15:11
Harry Potter and the Caliban Poltergeist

Do you mind if I nag for a bit? Thanks.

Yet there are several smaller lakes geographically scattered nearby, the nearest lake is called Secuutus Lake and yet it is this very lake the Hogsmeade villagers avoid. This is called a comma splice. It means that the clauses in the sentence are separated only by a comma, and nothing else. It's considered bad taste, as far as I know. You can rectify it like this:

Yet there are several smaller lakes geographically scattered nearby, and although the nearest lake is called Secuutus Lake, it is this very lake the Hogsmeade villagers avoid.

Or,

Yet there are several smaller lakes geographically scattered nearby; the nearest lake is called Secuutus Lake...

Or else,

Yet there are several smaller lakes geographically scattered nearby. The nearest lake is called Secuutus Lake, and yet it is this very lake the Hogsmeade villagers avoid.

More on the comma splice can be found here: http://webster.commnet.edu/grammar/runons.htm

three level stone and wood cottage - I'm not sure, but I think there should be a hyphen here: "three-level stone and wood cottage".

upper class Italians - same here: "upper-class Italians".

Sorry for nagging

 

As to the prologue itself, it was good, if a bit small. I think I'll read the next existing chapters first thing in the morning, after I've slept for a bit.

Best regards, - LoonyPhoenix
Bring and Fly
Sunday 31st October 2004 14:48
Harry Potter and the Caliban Poltergeist
Mmmm... Intriguing! Off to next chapter!
Cera
Sunday 31st October 2004 13:30
Harry Potter and the Caliban Poltergeist
This is a really good prologue.  Short, but effective.  The last paragraph especially pulls the reader in.