Authors: - A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P R S T V W X Y Z

Reviews For Consequences of the Mind by Mr. Intel

Prongs739
Thursday 28th August 2008 20:56
Consequences of the Mind
That was not real! That greasy little ferret did not beat Harry, and I will not believe it.

The was caught by ('').
harrysnotgoingtodiein7
Wednesday 18th July 2007 15:30
Consequences of the Mind
MALFOY beating harry?!?!?! no way ...

that cant have happened ....

but seriously, good story so far
ImmortalPhoenix
Tuesday 18th April 2006 09:51
Consequences of the Mind
Loved it as usual. My favorite sections were:
Ron's face turned red, but Harry just grinned. "You better not be thinking about my sister's...um, things, Harry. Or I'll have to Obliviate those particular images out of your head."

"What?" Harry asked with mock penitence. "Like you don't think about Hermione's things? She's just as much of a sister to me as Ginny is to you. So unless you're willing to stop lusting after her, I'm not going to stop, er..." Harry suddenly realized that the girls were both there when Ginny's hand moved rather quickly up the inside of his leg. "...thinking about Ginny," Harry finished with an oddly-strangled sound to his voice.

"Right, then," Hermione said. "Now that you've thoroughly discussed our things, let's get on with the book, shall we?"

I laughed for like... 5 minutes.
and
Harry's position on the bed presented a very pleasant view of Ginny and he found he couldn't seem to meet her eyes – something seemed very different about her, but he couldn't put his finger on what it was. "I can't help it, Ginny. Flying was everything to me – well, almost everything," he amended.

"Harry," she said, with a hint of exasperation. "Look me in the eyes when you're talking to me." She put her finger beneath his chin and tilted his face upward slightly and he saw a smirk playing around her lips. "Honestly, at least these things can get your attention now. Along with every other boy in the school," she lamented, cupping them with her hands in an exaggerated manner.

I think it would have been funny if Dean or Seamus or even Neville haha had commented on her little 'display' there but it was funny nonetheless.
NEED to read the next chapter lol...

Kortnee
Wooster
Saturday 14th January 2006 22:54
Consequences of the Mind

Oh gosh, poor Harry...though to tell the truth (don't be mad, Harry. Please!!!) I find it kind of, well, amusing that he's 'forgotten' how to fly when it's the one thing that ever came naturally to him. It's ironic and, in a way, funny! There is something seriously wrong with Cho though...sheesh.

Again, I have to applaud Harry for doing the smart thing and dodging the peer pressure of going into Quality Quidditch Supplies. Go Harry!

Hyperfried
Wednesday 3rd August 2005 19:26
Consequences of the Mind
Dobby's eyes grew large. "On, no, Master Harry. It's not a bother at all. We are happy to helps the great Harry Potter."

Yeah, there's your mistake. Other than that... Whew, wow. What a chapter! But how could you do such a thing to poor Harry?
sonicdale
Thursday 10th March 2005 21:56
Consequences of the Mind

Harry lost Quidditch?

Um, you'll have to redeem this, or I'll never read your stuff again. ARG.

Bloddy  !#$%7! fic writers! Making Harry all stupid and stuff! Don't you know he's a Quidditch GOD?

.....

...

Okay. Now that I've taken a walk around my room and had a drink, I feel better. But I'm still suprised. Hm. I HOPE this level of craziness continues, but I want some resolution.. I mean, I'm only human!

Mariposa
Sunday 16th January 2005 02:18
Consequences of the Mind

I loved how H/G pushed R/Hr together and the whole room cheered and they were all waiting for it to be over. I guess it was the show of the year. That was a really great scene. So did H/G  "know" they could do wandless magic already?

Griffins and Malfoy - more suspense *sigh*

Why did you chose blue to be the color of fear in the way Ginny sensed him? I thought that was an odd choice. And how could you make Harry forget to fly? That was a low blow. I've read the next chapter so it is cool with me. I actually enjoy the roller coaster this story has me in and am re-evaluating how much of a masochist exists within me, especially since this is supposed to be 20+ chapters and I only started it after you had 4 up. *sigh*

I love it when Ginny beats up on Harry and shakes him out of his moods. That was a very well done scene and always a fun bit. And that you restate that he doesn't need his glasses anymore is good because its hard to remember that little tidbit. H/G seem to recover quickly from thier side effects. Did the bond protect them from some of the side effects the learning spell? And will the rapid onset of puberty go away also?

I liked the whipped scene. It clearly illustrates that Harry would do anything for Ginny.

The Cho scene was twisted!?! She is really mental. But I would have liked to see the scene played out further because him just running out of there and then in McG's office kind of makes you wonder how he ended up getting caught. I think it would have been interesting even if it wasn't vital to the plot. Someone obviosly took Harry's wand away because he had to summon the spare one wandless.

The confrontation -Harry thinks Ginny is pretty when she's angry, talk about a boy in love. I like that Ginny sniffed him and could instantly smell Cho on him and then let the string of curses fly and knew it was the tart that forced herself on him. And then the bond again. I like that it helps keep things very simple between them and it prevents Harry from botching things up if he tried to explain in words.

The game- I have simply one word - sadist

Thanks to you and Kokopelli! Its going to be a great ride!

Katieay
Tuesday 30th November 2004 16:42
Consequences of the Mind

Awww Harry! Why couldn't he forget never losing to Malfoy? Then, he wouldn't be so upset.

I loved this:

 "You better not be thinking about my sister's...um, things, Harry. Or I'll have to Obliviate those particular images out of your head."

So Ron, and is Harry taking it so calmly and throwing it back to Ron part of his knew knowledge and growing up etc? I thought the whole scene was great, Harry's reaction just struck me a bit.

I love that you made me re-hate Cho! She gets a bit of a rough ride from the male authors here, but she completely deserves it  I'd really like to know Harry's going to get back at her

All in all, a great chapter! I couldn't mention everything I liked cause my review would be completely long (and would possibly turned silly/nutty )

On to chapter 5!

-- Katie

Tuesday 30th November 2004 17:43Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Cho's the kind of girl you love to hate.  We'll see how much she's hated by the end of the story, though.

Silly and/or nutty reviews are perfectly acceptable.
Bring and Fly
Monday 29th November 2004 06:36
Consequences of the Mind

Oh dear! I really do not like the sound of Malfoy looking a Harry triumphantly over the Griffin. That does not bode well.

This isn't Firebolt admiration day! Tee Hee! When is it then? That's a great line!

And as for Cho-that girl needs professional help. What are the adults at Hogwarts doing, for crying out loud? Hasn't anyone noticed she cracking up!?!?! However, having said that, I can't wait to see what Harry's plan is.

And the Snitch... I suppose Malfoy will now think he's the greatest Seeker since Josef Wronski and taunt Harry. Come on Ginny, point out to him that A: its not that big a deal (two misses in how many games?) and that B: if Harry hadn't had to concentrate on his flying, the outcome would have been the usual Malfoy defeat. Its a one-off.

It is a one-off, isn't it?

Monday 29th November 2004 09:28Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Yes, it is a one-off.  I think. 

Keep watching for the Griffin - or at least for a Griffin to appear again in the story.  It won't happen for a while.

Malfoy's head is quite large at this point, and we'll get to see the git again, hopefully getting it properly punctured.
ice princess
Tuesday 23rd November 2004 22:49
Consequences of the Mind
Another amazing chapter!  I just love this story and am so glad you decided to do a sequel to Consequences of the Heart.  Keep up the excellent work and update soon!
SillyGillie
Tuesday 23rd November 2004 20:04
Consequences of the Mind

OMG!!!!!
That's sacreligious making Malfoy catch the snitch!!! Urgh I hate Malfoy! Stupid bastard!
Poor Harry!!! I can't believe he forgot how to fly!! Aww! That's so sad, that was his only release, well, except for Ginny prehaps.
Urgh, Malfoy's going to fluant it in Harry's face every chance he gets, well the Slytherin team lost anyway didn't they? Or...maybe not the score was 160 to 40, so that means they lost.  
Post some more soon! Poor Harry!

Tuesday 23rd November 2004 20:38Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Sacrieligious, eh?  More along the lines of going against the grain, but I get you're drift. 

Gryffindor lost, sadly.  I hated to do that, but the story simply demanded an early loss for Gryffindor.  We'll see how well they do in upcoming matches.
lizzyrose89
Tuesday 23rd November 2004 15:21
Consequences of the Mind

Oh buggery!

What is it with Song authors and their need tohave Harry miss the Snitch??  I reckon it's some kind of disease!

Great story - can't wait for the update!

Oh, quick question - how can Harry have forgotten how to fly?  He was pretty bloody good on his very first try with absolutely no training at all in PS.  Does the spell Dumbledore cast meddle with something other than memory instead?  Not trying to nitpick - just interested.

Lizzy xxx

Tuesday 23rd November 2004 20:36Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Is that a trend?  I hadn't noticed. 

Read some of the replies to other reviews for this chapter to answer your question.  It's also addressed by Kokopelli's review to some extent.

-M
Kokopelli
Monday 22nd November 2004 22:01
Consequences of the Mind
A bit about this and that:

As to the flying  - part of growing older is learning that sometimes your body (previously thought of as indestructable) can lose functions and bits - think of losing an adult tooth.  This is what has happened to Harry - comparable to having a stroke.  Harry's no stranger to loss - this is just one in a different dimension.

As to losing at Quidditch, apart from the game in his 3rd year when the Dementors came to play, Harry wins every time he flies.  He's long overdue to experience what the rest of us experience - sometimes our best just isn't good enough.

In each instance, this is something that happens in real life - the important thing is not the loss, but how we deal with it.

JEC
Monday 22nd November 2004 23:17Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Thanks, John.  I couldn't have put it better.
ViviRed75
Monday 22nd November 2004 21:57
Consequences of the Mind
I love it! When I read the first story, I wasn't sure you would be able to top such brilliance. But this is incredible!! I can't wait to read more. The Cho scene was splendid. I hope she loses her Headgirl badge. Evil cackle.
Monday 22nd November 2004 23:13Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
It warms the cackles of this author to be on the recieving end of such praise.  I hope that I don't peak out at some point and end of dissapointing you. 

Cho's fate will definitely be addressed in the next chapter.
Aberforth's Avatar
Monday 22nd November 2004 20:03
Consequences of the Mind

I was surprised that you selected flying as the magical skill that Harry forgot.  I would think that it would be more a matter of hand-eye coordination and muscle memory.  I don't remember that flying was something that Harry learned.  Wasn't it more of a natural skill?  That is my biggest complaint about the chapter. 

There were many things that I liked.  Harry and Ginny giving Ron and Hermione gentle nudges.  Ron's passion in asserting his desire for an open relationship with Hermione.  Harry and Ginny increasingly comfortable with each other and able to sense each others' emotions and thoughts.  McGonagall with Harry and Cho.  All worked well; no, they worked very well.  I especially liked the way that this chapter fleshed out the details from Chapter 3.  I don't like the way that it ended -- I can't see Harry being beaten by Malfoy -- but it leaves no substantive issues unanswered.

Monday 22nd November 2004 23:12Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
I wouldn't necessarily characterize flying as a 'magical skill'.  See some of my other review responses for more information on what and why, as well as Kokopelli's excellent review.

Thank you for telling me that you thought worked...it's one of the only ways I have to gauge my success.  I'm also glad you can't see Harry being beaten by Malfoy - it's another mark of succes, in my book.  To write something unexpected that catches people off guard is one of my chief aims.
brios
Monday 22nd November 2004 19:15
Consequences of the Mind

In moments like that last scene, (Harry's reaction of losing the snitch to Malfoy) it's when one realize that we're really talking about kids and puberty, the best and worst times of someones life.    It would be interesting to see how JKR developes those characters.

Great chapter as always.

Monday 22nd November 2004 23:09Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Thanks for that, brios.  I agree... we really *are* talking about kids, here.  No matter how grown up we may want them to be at times.


Shadow Hider
Monday 22nd November 2004 18:14
Consequences of the Mind
oh wow.  can't wait to read the next chapter!
blinieldar
Monday 22nd November 2004 09:31
Consequences of the Mind
Malfoy catching the snitch is just...Wrong.  I'm really curious to see where all this with Cho is heading too. Questions answered; Questions asked
Monday 22nd November 2004 10:38Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Questions are the fun part of story telling.  If you can tell where the story is headed, where's the fun in it?  
Neely61
Monday 22nd November 2004 09:19
Consequences of the Mind
O.M.G!  caught the snitch?  Isn't that like, one of the the signs of the apocalypse or something?   Anyhoo, great chapter.  Loved the conversation about "things"!   Can't wait to see what happens with  and  's training in wandless magic.  Where's  off to at the end of this chap?  Don't want him getting into more trouble do we?   Is Cho going to lose her head girl status?  Was she being controlled?  Too many questions, not enuf updates!   Stop reading this and get back in bed with your muse!
Monday 22nd November 2004 10:37Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
LOL.  Yeah, I think the end is near.  Next sign is that Slytherin wins the House Cup and Malfoy becomes Head Boy.   I wouldn't be *that* wicked, would I?

Wandless Magic is obviously a useful tool.  Voldemort has certainly discovered some of its secrets, no?  Harry's fate will be seen at the beginning of chapter five (which is already under way).  Ginny will be there for him, don't you worry.

My muse and I have a strange relationship.  I've decided that she's a slut - only visits me when it's convenient for her and only puts out when she's ready for it.  Most good writers can work through muse difficulties, so we'll have to see if I can build up my skills in that area.
Antonia East
Monday 22nd November 2004 09:17
Consequences of the Mind
Poor ol' Harry - beaten by Malfoy.  I hope Ginny gets hims into the air again.  Flying's about the only thing he ever felt naturally good it.  Bet he wishes the spell had removed some of the memories he has nightmares about as well.  I like the little messages Ginny and Harry send eachother about speaking.  The learning spell seems like a really interesting idea.  I love how complicted you've made it - how many side-effects it has. 
Monday 22nd November 2004 10:34Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Aren't I wicked?  Malfoy's *really* having a good day, isn't he.  I suppose that makes Harry having a back time of it, though.

Ginny's good for Harry - I think that's pretty much unanimous here.  So she's definitely going to be involved in his 'recovery'.

For the learning spell...I've always wanted it to be complicated.  It seemed like if I made it just transferring knowledge, it would be more of a 'super power' spell and would seem less credible.  Since it's so early in the story, we'll have to see if my solution works or not.
SiblingCreature
Monday 22nd November 2004 08:31
Consequences of the Mind
*snickers*   ok I've read the other reviews now...   I see I'm not the the only one who sees it that way. :-) 

Incidently I love it how Harry can just show his experiences to Ginny like that... one can avoid so many misunderstandings that way :-)
Monday 22nd November 2004 10:31Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
No...definitely not the only one.   One way to guarantee reviews, I suppose, is to write something into the story that no one expects and that goes against something they really think isn't possible.  I hope things are worked out to your satisfaction as the rest of the plot develops.
SiblingCreature
Monday 22nd November 2004 08:15
Consequences of the Mind
While I'm very much enjoying this story there's something about this chapter that just doesn't sit right with me... Harry forgetting how to fly doesn't make much sense to me...  it wasn't something he learned in the first place, it was something he just... did...  instinctively...   I can understand him having trouble remembering how to get started, but once he got in the air....  *shrugs*  

In any case I loook forward to the next chapter :-)
XiaoXiao
Monday 22nd November 2004 01:47
Consequences of the Mind

She was beautiful but eeevil...(Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, if you didn't already know).

I loved how Ginny was willing to communicate and find out what happened, instead of flying off the handle. 

Poor Harry!  Not having his flying skills sounds really dreadful.  I hope that he can remember them soon.

Great job; can't wait for more!

Monday 22nd November 2004 10:29Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Thanks for reading and for finding good in this chapter.  I really tried to mix some good in with the bad.
mgmerlin
Sunday 21st November 2004 22:59
Consequences of the Mind
Yeah, my review is just below (Mike), and I'd just to say that I didn't know you've already addressed the issue of Harry's loss of flying skills.  Sorry.  On another note, I'd dearly like to know what has happened to Dumbledore, or more specifically when he'll make his re-appearance as I think it's fairly obvious what that spell has done to him.  I wonder if he'll ever fully recover.
Sunday 21st November 2004 23:12Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Thanks for reading my replies to other reviewers.  It's tough to repeat myself ten times. 

As to Dumbledore, he makes an appearance in chapter six, assuming my timeline stays intact.

He won't be quite the same, no.  I'm afraid his sacrifice was just that, and the poor man lost something for his efforts.  Voldemort will be most pleased when he finds out.
Kelleypen
Sunday 21st November 2004 22:50
Consequences of the Mind
I enjoyed this.  I don't think Harry would forget to fly, since he never had to learn.  For him, flying was like breathing; it came that naturally. Just my opinion.  I'll have to think some more about this evil Cho.  Too bad we can't set her up with someone else.
Sunday 21st November 2004 23:09Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
See my response to Amulder's review on Harrys flying.

It wasn't a whim.  Also, Evil!Cho serves her own purpose, too.  Never underestimate the power of love...or magic.
p0tterfan
Sunday 21st November 2004 22:27
Consequences of the Mind
Great chapter ... out of character for Cho to act that way I would think.  If Dumbledore makes her head-girl, there would have to be some reason for that decision.  Just a nitpick :)

Great chapter nevertheless.  Looking forward to Harry's reaction on losing, and finding about the Griffin's reaction to and .
Sunday 21st November 2004 23:07Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
I'm glad someone finally brought up Cho.  There are two camps, I've found, on her - the Cho-haters, who see her as the spawn of evil, and the Cho sympathizers, who see her as basically good, but not necessarily important.

You get to see both in my story.  There's a reason for Cho to act the way she is, and you'll find out why in due time.  Try not to judge on chapter's peek at a character without seeing the rest of the plot?  Thanks.
wvchemteach
Sunday 21st November 2004 22:22
Consequences of the Mind

I just have to say that Harry will be a long time recovering from this (although snogs from Ginny  will make the best medicine). You have basically taken from him the one thing about himself that he ever felt he had a right to take pride in...his flying ability.  Remember in GOF it was the only thing he thought that he was good at.

That would be the equivalent of taking Hermione's  knowledge of Hogwarts, A History, Ron's  love of the Canons, or the Twins sense of humor.

Harry in this chapter has lost a major piece of who he sees himself to be and it is going to be difficult for him to recover and move forward from this.

You just drove the knife in, however, by making him lose to Ferret-face.

I can deal with this set back, however, if you do have it in the plans for Harry to somehow save face.

Other than flying and his glasses...just what else has Harry lost?

Just be careful as to how low you let Harry go...Ginny will not put up with too much brooding or sulking and if she gets fed up enough with him...he'll have lost everything.

Sunday 21st November 2004 23:05Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
I hear what you're saying.  However, taking away that thing from Harry sets up something that I hope will lead to a better, more capable Harry.  When one needs to destroy the ultimate evil loser of the universe, one must be prepared.  My way of doing that is to build him from the ground up, and there's nothing better to do that with than to tear him down first.  Harry had to know pain in ways he's not experienced before in order to have the mental skills to beat Voldemort.  This was not taken lightly and is important to the plot.

Harry has lost more than what we've already seen, but it's all relatively minor.  That is, until Summer.  I'll wait to let you see that one in the next story.

Let me go on record right now and say that Harry will absolutely *not* lose Ginny in the story.  He won't lose Ginny ever, if my muse will cooperate with me.  He needs her more than ever, and will need her to fulfill the prophesy.

That's all I'm going to say about that.
mary-v
Sunday 21st November 2004 21:22
Consequences of the Mind

Right, well, I just sent you an unsigned review! Just wanted to let you know it was me! I really do love this thing! lol

~Maria~

parakletos
Sunday 21st November 2004 20:37
Consequences of the Mind
Poor Harry,  you really want to put him through it don't you? First, he 'loses' Ginny, gets set up by Cho and now Malfoy beats him to the snitch! Any one would think you didn't like the boy ! Good chapter look forward to the next
Sunday 21st November 2004 20:49Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
  Yep... I've got it in for the poor boy.  But I did arrange a few snogs for him throughout to help him cope.  Ginny's good for him.  But, I have to say that Harry's problems have only just begun.
Iris
Sunday 21st November 2004 20:01
Consequences of the Mind
Evil!Cho and Malfoy actually winning a quiditch match

poor harry, although i love the interaction between him and ginny.

Can't wait till the next installment

~Iris
Sunday 21st November 2004 20:03Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Thanks, Iris.  With the Quidditch thing, I figured that I'd do something that had never been done before.  Besides...what's more important? Winning against the ferret, or killing the Moldiepants?  
Kinsfire
Sunday 21st November 2004 19:25
Consequences of the Mind
"Yeah, right," Harry replied. "I'm not worried about Ginny leaving me for Michael just like I'm not worried about Cho. That ship sailed, burned and sank with total loss of all hands, Hermione, and you, of all people, should know it."

No, Harry, tell us what you REALLY think!  *snort*  I loved this!

Interesting the way Hogwarts is run, mind you.  At any OTHER school, Chang would be expelled for her actions.  Here, she'll get a stern talking to and be allowed to keep stalking Harry.
Sunday 21st November 2004 20:02Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Actually, her punishment just hasn't been brought up yet.  You'll get to hear her fate in chapter five.  She did NOT get off easy.  Suffice it to say, Cho won't be featuring in Harry's future after this episode. 
amulder
Sunday 21st November 2004 18:45
Consequences of the Mind
Great Job, again.

Minor nit - Madame Malkin's is in Diagon Alley, and Gladrags is in Hogsmeade.

Most curious to learn the fate of Cho.  Surely, McGonagall will have dealt out some sort of punishment.

I do wonder about losing the knowledge of flying.  After all, that's not something he ever learned in the first place.  He just jumped on a broom in book 1 and took off.  No training no nothing, just a complete natural.  That's a pretty fundamental thing to have lost.  Hmm.

thanks for sharing.
Sunday 21st November 2004 20:05Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Thanks, Art.  I'll fix the nit.  My canon hat was obviously at the cleaners when I wrote that one. 

As to Harry's flying ability, yeah...he's a natural, and that will come into play in the coming chapters, but *anything* can be erased from the mind, even innate skills.  Obliviate is only one example.  Keep reading - I can't make everything sensible on a chapter by chapter basis! 
Bucky01
Sunday 21st November 2004 18:22
Consequences of the Mind

 I love your stories but I feel I must point out that Harry didn't learn to fly... he was a natural at it.

 

Sunday 21st November 2004 20:06Consequences of the Mind (Author Response)
Trust me enough to read the upcoming chapters... Harry's flying skills will be addressed further.