adamstrage500
Thursday 14th May 2009 12:41 | The Good In Me Is Dead |
| i loved it a very dark and devestational outlook on what could ahve been of the final battle |
QuidditchLover
Friday 9th November 2007 05:58 | The Good In Me Is Dead |
| that was kinda morbid.emilygail0323@aol.com |
pyromain
Monday 25th June 2007 13:05 | The Good In Me Is Dead |
| It is writen really good, but I didn't like the plot to depressing for me, I come here to leave the depression of life behind and now i find a story of life. |
lacyrachil
Tuesday 5th December 2006 13:59 | The Good In Me Is Dead |
| Very dark and poignant...I hope this isn't a foretelling of things to come. |
| Wednesday 6th December 2006 10:57 | The Good In Me Is Dead (Author Response) |
| Me too Glad you enjoyed it. |
MagnoliaMama
Sunday 15th January 2006 15:51 | The Good In Me Is Dead |
| What a fascinating concept, for Voldemort to yank the magic out of everything close to him as a final act of hatred; I'd love to see that explored in a longer fic, examining the long-term consequences of his action (though maybe not with all the casualties, eh?). A very atmospheric and powerful story, if perhaps a wee bit on the depressing side.
|
| Sunday 15th January 2006 16:15 | The Good In Me Is Dead (Author Response) |
Casualties? What casualties? Dunno what you mean!
But seriously I'm glad you liked it, it was interesting to write something other than fun & fluff.
|
SillyGillie
Tuesday 18th October 2005 18:08 | The Good In Me Is Dead |
| Really profound and sad. Nice job. |
| Wednesday 19th October 2005 09:12 | The Good In Me Is Dead (Author Response) |
| Thanks, glad you liked it.
|
Connor Landon
Saturday 17th September 2005 17:52 | The Good In Me Is Dead |
| Wonderfully sad! |
Drie
Monday 20th June 2005 10:41 | The Good In Me Is Dead |
| You're truly evil. Even though I was ready for a dark fic from you... Nicely done. I always enjoy your work, and so glad to see this story taking shape! |
| Monday 20th June 2005 15:13 | The Good In Me Is Dead (Author Response) |
| Me evil? don't know why you think that!
|
Thunder's Shadow
Sunday 19th June 2005 11:53 | The Good In Me Is Dead |
::coughs::
Er, that was extremely, extremely good...But awfully depressing!
Either way, though, it was wonderful. Great writing, really.
signed,
Sam |
| Sunday 19th June 2005 11:57 | The Good In Me Is Dead (Author Response) |
| Thanks glad you <strike>enjoyed</strike> liked it.
|
Kelleypen
Sunday 19th June 2005 07:28 | The Good In Me Is Dead |
| You poor morose author! I'll hope the good side of the HP force will reclaim you soon. Sending light energy your way------ |
| Sunday 19th June 2005 07:51 | The Good In Me Is Dead (Author Response) |
| Just ask Baffy, if she she thinks my fluffy side has been reclaimed - she's probably still pulling bits of candy-floss from between her teeth! - for refrence see a forthcoming outake in a couple of weeks. |
Arnel
Sunday 19th June 2005 00:36 | The Good In Me Is Dead |
| I feel compelled to review this "cheery little number" just because I'm hoping Book 7 of canon doesn't end in quite this way. Poor Harry! Everybody he cares about dead except for Hermine and Molly. I hope they find him and he accepts their succor. You've done an admirable job of creating such a horrible end to Voldemort's reign of terror. |
| Sunday 19th June 2005 06:33 | The Good In Me Is Dead (Author Response) |
| Too right! I really do hope that JKR does nothing like this in book seven. As for Hermione and Molly, well they're both very determined ladies, I'm sure once they find him they won't let go until he's better. |
Delfino
Saturday 18th June 2005 18:33 | The Good In Me Is Dead |
| Wow. I've never read anything that powerful. I love reading your stories but this one was....amazing. I've never heard the song before, but the way you wrote this.....Just...wow. It was so sad, but not that kind of frusterating sadness where you wonder what ever possessed the author to do this. It was the sadness that you realize that this could happen in the actual series. This is, by far, one of the best stories I have ever read. |
| Sunday 19th June 2005 06:26 | The Good In Me Is Dead (Author Response) |
Wow, what can I say, that is praise indeed. Thank-you
was so sad, but not that kind of frusterating sadness where you wonder what ever possessed the author to do this. It was the sadness that you realize that this could happen in the actual series.
I don't know about that... I've looked at the story a few times since I finished it and wondered where an earth it came from!!! |
juliet
Saturday 18th June 2005 17:20 | The Good In Me Is Dead |
| Well, that was certainly a cheery little read for a Sunday morning! Well written Bart - as always.
|
| Saturday 18th June 2005 17:55 | The Good In Me Is Dead (Author Response) |
| Thanks, I wasn't sure if I had over done the fluff myself...
|
