gymnastgal19
Tuesday 30th October 2007 20:35 | Fighting Voldemort |
I liked this story!
|
lacyrachil
Tuesday 14th November 2006 12:46 | Fighting Voldemort |
| I really enjoyed this story. It put a new spin on the real books themselves. Thanks for writing it. |
| Tuesday 14th November 2006 14:23 | Fighting Voldemort (Author Response) |
| Wow, thanks for this nice review! Neville's always been someone special to me with his own kind of courage and his own ways to deal with certain situations. |
Chatmandu
Tuesday 14th November 2006 11:54 | Fighting Voldemort |
"They also serve who only stand and wait." Stalwart Neville (yeah!), bristling Ginny, and those who stand at Harry's side whether he knows it or not.
This is a nice vignette of Harry's seventh year! Thanks for giving us a view of what happens with some of the other major characters. Those who stand and wait. |
| Tuesday 14th November 2006 14:21 | Fighting Voldemort (Author Response) |
| Thank you very much for your nice review! I agree with you that those "behind the scenes" are just as important as those who fight at the front. They're just less visible. |
anniep
Tuesday 14th November 2006 05:23 | Fighting Voldemort |
| Ginny and Neville both were excellently in character. I really liked his quiet strength, how he showed her that there's more than one way to fight, and made her think past her perceptions of how her family was treating her. Thanks for sharing your story. |
| Tuesday 14th November 2006 09:00 | Fighting Voldemort (Author Response) |
| Thank you so much for your lovely review! Neville's own kind of strength and of courage are maybe a bit different than Harry's, but very valuable nonetheless. I'm glad you liked him! |
Kamalia
Monday 13th November 2006 18:47 | Fighting Voldemort |
| That was great! We don't often get a good look at Ginny and Neville together. And although Ginny was a bit whinier than I picture her, I think you captured Neville exceedingly well. Kudos! |
| Tuesday 14th November 2006 08:58 | Fighting Voldemort (Author Response) |
| Thank you very much for your nice review! I'm glad you enjoyed the fic. Ginny's certainly someone about whose reaction we could argue for hours - it's just the way I see her and, remember, learning for Potions doesn't brush up your mood very much. So we'll just have to wait for book 7 and see how JKR will do it... |
Grandma Kate
Monday 13th November 2006 17:30 | Fighting Voldemort |
| Your Neville is very true. |
| Tuesday 14th November 2006 08:23 | Fighting Voldemort (Author Response) |
| Thanks for your review! I'm glad you liked his characterization! |
daniel_r_crazy22
Monday 13th November 2006 15:27 | Fighting Voldemort |
| That wasn't what I expected, but it was still very good. And Neville does have a point. |
| Tuesday 14th November 2006 08:22 | Fighting Voldemort (Author Response) |
| Well, now I'm curious what you did expect I'm glad you liked it, even though it was something different. Thanks for your review! |
GryffindorDragon
Monday 13th November 2006 13:14 | Fighting Voldemort |
Very nice.
I like how you portray Ginny's frustration -- very real.
I also like how you bring her around to something positive.
|
| Monday 13th November 2006 15:23 | Fighting Voldemort (Author Response) |
| Thanks for your nice review! I'm glad you like Ginny's characterization; I just can't see her being too happy about being sent back to Hogwarts in book 7 (And I'm certain that Molly won't allow her baby to accompany the trio.). |
topbabe
Monday 13th November 2006 09:45 | Fighting Voldemort |
| COOL! when is the next 1 commin???? wb x lve hols |
| Monday 13th November 2006 15:20 | Fighting Voldemort (Author Response) |
| Thanks for your nice review! As this is a one-shot, there'll be no other chapter, but if you're interested in some of my writing, just have a look at my author's page here at PS. |
Ladybug
Monday 13th November 2006 03:21 | Fighting Voldemort |
Wow!
That is fantastic!
Really, that is very very good supposition on what might face Ginny soon. I can't believe how wonderful Neville is - well, yes I can, actually! But I love how wonderful he is. And you've got Ginny's voice so perfectly right. There are so many lines I love - I love Neville's resemblance to a 'determined Harry' and I love the little explanation of how, actually, no one has told Ginny she's useless and that they've been helping her not to be.
Great work. I really love it. |
| Monday 13th November 2006 15:19 | Fighting Voldemort (Author Response) |
| Thank you so much for your review! I simply love Neville, and he just has to play an important role in book 7. He deserves so much more attention than he gets and he's such a wonderful character. Thanks also for your compliments on Ginny's characterization; I just can't see Molly allowing her to leave with the trio. |
