Authors: - A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P R S T V W X Y Z

Reviews For That Terrifying Momentum by Caleb Nova

kopfsalat2000
Sunday 14th October 2012 16:59
That Terrifying Momentum
Hello there,
I might have been a little harsh in my last review - let me make it up to you by saying that this chapter was fine and just made me want more of that stuff
Cheers.
Monday 15th October 2012 02:21That Terrifying Momentum (Author Response)
Well, there's a little more to be had.
kickedabyss
Tuesday 2nd August 2011 05:32
That Terrifying Momentum
Uhm. Cliffhanger anyone? This story took some getting used to, but in terms of interesting reads and proper use of the English language it gets top marks.

I need more! Why does it say completed!?
Sunday 21st August 2011 01:16That Terrifying Momentum (Author Response)
Uhm. Cliffhanger anyone? This story took some getting used to, but in terms of interesting reads and proper use of the English language it gets top marks.


Thank you. I know it was a difficult concept, but I tried very hard to sell it.

I need more! Why does it say completed!?


Because this story is completed. There won't be any more chapters for That Terrifying Momentum. There may, however, be more chapters of something else.
The Pharaoh
Saturday 16th July 2011 18:14
That Terrifying Momentum
P.S. Although I stand by what I said before, I must admit that in cases such as the one you presented in the last chapter/author's note (C/A/N ?) where the future status of the story is unclear, a short chapter with less wait time can be more satisfying in bringing the news earlier that the story will continue.
Though sincere and original, this came to my mind when I read another review after posting mine. In your response to that review, you said the next phase was in the works, but in your response to other reviews you called this an epilogue-type piece. So now I am confused and anxious again; is this the end of your work on this story, or not?
Sunday 31st July 2011 03:46That Terrifying Momentum (Author Response)
P.S. Although I stand by what I said before, I must admit that in cases such as the one you presented in the last chapter/author's note (C/A/N ?) where the future status of the story is unclear, a short chapter with less wait time can be more satisfying in bringing the news earlier that the story will continue.


Probably.

Though sincere and original, this came to my mind when I read another review after posting mine. In your response to that review, you said the next phase was in the works, but in your response to other reviews you called this an epilogue-type piece. So now I am confused and anxious again; is this the end of your work on this story, or not?


This story is finished. There won't be another chapter of That Terrifying Momentum. As for whether there will be more chapters of something else... I've done some work, but nothing is finalized.
The Pharaoh
Saturday 16th July 2011 18:01
That Terrifying Momentum
I've said it before I think, but I don't know about the majority of readers, but I presonally find long chapters to be better, and very long chapters to be best, especially when chapters are months+ apart. I would rather wait longer and read a more substantial chapter than have more, shorter chapters and more frequently relive the frustration and anxiety of having nothing left to read in one of my favorite stories ever and wanting to read more. That said, it is of course up to you.
Regarding the elements of the chapter itself, it seems as close to a "filler" episode of an anime series as I can remember seeing in writing off the top of my head (though that doesn't say much as I can rarely recall much off the top of myy head). I mean this only in the sense of the role a filler episode plays in relation to the entire series, not to compare your work with anime. It displays certain known characteristics of main charaters (mostly Scott) without moving the plot forward, almost like a rehash, and most likely is meant to hold the audience over until something of more densely plot-moving content substance is developed and put out. For example, it seemed like you were playing up Scott's verbal wit; his careless?/playful? personality (I don't really know how to describe it), with his climbing in through the window and sitting on the swings' bar; and his war-centric professionalism where Harry, etc. would balk, with the bait idea.

I understand this is the last period of time when Harry could be reasonably expected to come near Surrey or that playground, but is your mentioning the concept of coming full circle, and writing this scene in the first place, way before the story's over, a reflection of uncertainty about/unwillingness to continue writing this story that you might have?
Sunday 31st July 2011 03:44That Terrifying Momentum (Author Response)
I've said it before I think, but I don't know about the majority of readers, but I presonally find long chapters to be better, and very long chapters to be best, especially when chapters are months+ apart. I would rather wait longer and read a more substantial chapter than have more, shorter chapters and more frequently relive the frustration and anxiety of having nothing left to read in one of my favorite stories ever and wanting to read more. That said, it is of course up to you.


I usually write a chapter until I think it's done. The chapters are unified with a common theme or just a single period of time, or maybe even a series of events that I wanted captured in one go. When that's done, so is the chapter. In the middle of the story this lead to some very long sections, long enough I felt it prudent to cut them in half. Later, when some of the plot was more action oriented, the chapters became shorter. There's no definable method to it... I stop a chapter when I think it should be stopped.

Regarding the elements of the chapter itself, it seems as close to a "filler" episode of an anime series as I can remember seeing in writing off the top of my head (though that doesn't say much as I can rarely recall much off the top of myy head). I mean this only in the sense of the role a filler episode plays in relation to the entire series, not to compare your work with anime.


I'm glad you're not making that comparison, because I can't stand anime.

It displays certain known characteristics of main charaters (mostly Scott) without moving the plot forward, almost like a rehash, and most likely is meant to hold the audience over until something of more densely plot-moving content substance is developed and put out. For example, it seemed like you were playing up Scott's verbal wit; his careless?/playful? personality (I don't really know how to describe it), with his climbing in through the window and sitting on the swings' bar; and his war-centric professionalism where Harry, etc. would balk, with the bait idea.


It's an epilogue, nothing else. It brings things back where they started, answers a few questions, and leaves room for more.

I understand this is the last period of time when Harry could be reasonably expected to come near Surrey or that playground


That's true, but not really the point.

but is your mentioning the concept of coming full circle, and writing this scene in the first place, way before the story's over, a reflection of uncertainty about/unwillingness to continue writing this story that you might have?


Yes and no. If I decided not to continue (or to leave it sitting for some time) then I wanted a better closing chapter than I left you with. If I chose to continue immediately, then I set the stage for the next part. Which of these decisions I made is not entirely clear to me yet.
xaphanea
Sunday 19th June 2011 21:05
That Terrifying Momentum
I'm so incredibly excited. I was hoping so badly that you would continue this story. Bravo! An excellent start to the next phase of your story! I laughed rather heartily over Harry getting aroused about Ginny all tied up. ;D Keep it up!
Tuesday 5th July 2011 02:15That Terrifying Momentum (Author Response)
I'm so incredibly excited. I was hoping so badly that you would continue this story. Bravo! An excellent start to the next phase of your story!


Still undecided what the next phase will be, but it's in the works.

I laughed rather heartily over Harry getting aroused about Ginny all tied up.


And, really, what's not arousing about that?

Keep it up!


And a very sincere 'keep on truckin'' to you too.
scwatcher
Monday 13th June 2011 23:23
That Terrifying Momentum
And here I thought Scott and Harry were on an extended sabbatical.

Your line, "And core competencies is pointless business jargon designed to express a very simple concept in a complicated way so that it takes up more time at meetings,” Scott explained." is one of the painful truths of being in the corporate world.

Synergy, ecumenical and self evaluation are more of the same. The amount of life that can leak away in meetings is astounding.

Thanks for the update.
Tuesday 5th July 2011 02:09That Terrifying Momentum (Author Response)
And here I thought Scott and Harry were on an extended sabbatical.


They were, for a time. What comes next is still up in the air, but at least partially written.

Your line, "And core competencies is pointless business jargon designed to express a very simple concept in a complicated way so that it takes up more time at meetings,” Scott explained." is one of the painful truths of being in the corporate world.


I just enjoy deliberately obtuse expressions like that. Especially synergy. Synergy!

Thanks for the update.


Thanks for the review.
glacialis1
Monday 13th June 2011 22:51
That Terrifying Momentum
Not exactly your most exciting chapter, of course any Chapter with Scott's sarcasm is worth reading. I am just excited you have decided to continue. I like that you had Harry and Scott return to where it all started for them, very poetic. Can't wait to see what comes next.
Tuesday 5th July 2011 02:07That Terrifying Momentum (Author Response)
It's just a little epilogue. I wasn't trying to be exciting or drop big plot revelations. It's my outro. Glad you enjoyed the sarcasm.
Dad
Monday 13th June 2011 12:12
That Terrifying Momentum
Good talk, though the plot did not advance too much. It may have needed an Author`s note (No. That`s a lie)!
Tuesday 5th July 2011 02:06That Terrifying Momentum (Author Response)
Yeah, it didn't need a note. It's an epilogue, and I think I tested everyone's patience with the previous chapter.
Chatmandu
Monday 13th June 2011 11:34
That Terrifying Momentum
Well...

5 points for the clever canon way of letting us know how to correctly pronounce Scott's name and race. 10 points for not using Viktor Krum to do it.
Tuesday 5th July 2011 02:06That Terrifying Momentum (Author Response)
I think I should have earned triple points if I'd figured out some way to shoehorn Krum into this story at all. I don't know why or how I could possibly use him.
kori24601
Sunday 12th June 2011 00:51
That Terrifying Momentum
Awesome, Caleb! I was so happy to see that you added another chapter! I love the fact that Scott is showing up in the middle of the night and throwing rocks at Harry's window so they can "plan" lol. His "back up plan" is great!

It was also good to see Harry still thinking about Ginny. There hasn't been much Ginny and she's easy to forget about, good to know Harry hasn't forgotten her!

Your story is pure genius. I already know what's going to happen in a general sense, but it is so different and creative that it pulls me in and reminds me that I don't know what's going to happen at all lol.

Thanks so much for continuing this story!!!!!!!
Tuesday 5th July 2011 02:05That Terrifying Momentum (Author Response)
Awesome, Caleb! I was so happy to see that you added another chapter! I love the fact that Scott is showing up in the middle of the night and throwing rocks at Harry's window so they can "plan" lol. His "back up plan" is great!


But were you as happy as I am to see another review? We should compare notes.

And yes, it's less of a backup plan and more of a doomsday scenario. Presumably, Harry wouldn't survive to see it.

It was also good to see Harry still thinking about Ginny. There hasn't been much Ginny and she's easy to forget about, good to know Harry hasn't forgotten her!


It's true that Ginny didn't show up much for the first half of the story, but I think she has a strong presence by the end. And hey, cut me a little slack. She has like, four lines in the real book six (and certainly no scenes from her POV).

Your story is pure genius. I already know what's going to happen in a general sense, but it is so different and creative that it pulls me in and reminds me that I don't know what's going to happen at all lol.


I like that description.

Thanks so much for continuing this story!!!!!!!


Thank you even more for continuing to review!