Register | Login

Reviews For Lessons for Life by Caitlyn

Review Navigation:PreviousNextShow All
Showing 1 to 3 of 3
Sunday 17th June 2007 02:31

Hogwarts alumni
Num. of Reviews: 580

2: Hogwarts
I already love Chloe, she sounds a bit like another of my favorite characters by the name of Ginny.
Thursday 6th July 2006 07:46

Hogwarts alumni
Num. of Reviews: 1230

2: Hogwarts
Oooh. Think I might like this girl. She seems out there.
Disassembly of Reason
Sunday 17th April 2005 18:26

1st year
Num. of Reviews: 17

2: Hogwarts

[I]Lessons for Life[/I], chapter 2, "Hogwarts"

This chapter is a very close match for that on, with just a handful of retouches.

Meme list (professional): Auror!Harry, Auror!Ron, teaching-professional!Hermione(Arithmancy)

Meme list (relationships): established!relationship(Ron/Hermione, marriage), established!relationship(Dudley/OC, marriage, 5 years), established!relationship(Percy/Penelope, marriage)

Meme list: abusive!Dursleys(emotional), wizarding-kid!Dursleys(daughter, rejected), adoptive-father!Harry(Dudley's daughter)

[You don't scare ME with all this backstory.]


Abbreviations herein:
PA = [I]Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban[/I]
PS = [I]Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone[/I]
OP = [I]Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix[/I]


I like the touch of Dumbledore, despite the seriousness of the war - or really, because of it - having yanked Harry's chain continually during the war with a choice of weird Apparition points. This pre-OP Harry was a good sport about it, and took it as it was meant: an affectionate way of giving both of them a laugh, and of keeping things in perspective.

Since the earlier draft was posted on, the text has been revised a little; Harry is now a little uncomfortable under McGonagall's formidable gaze, after eight years away.

At Hogwarts and inside the classroom, McGonagall always refers to current students by [title] [surname], while with students with whom she's friendly, she reverts to [surname only] outside the classroom. Judging from her referring James and Lily by their given names in SS1, however, I think that with students she's particularly fond of, she might relax and use their given names once they're out of school. I think she'd be calling Harry "Harry", once she'd put aside her mock-annoyance and hugged him.

I'd recommend actually naming the magazine the two boys are carrying, here, not just calling it "a Quidditch magazine". Since this is Harry's POV, and he actually picks it up and gets a good look at it, he'd recognize it (and the magazine title should tell the reader roughly what it's about). Also, "Beater" takes a capital letter. A pity that in this AU Harry never had a chance to play professional Quidditch, but understandable; the war hasn't been over for long, and he has a sense of duty that might keep him from pursuing a career purely for fun anyway.

Dear Harry; the fame has never done him any good, so I'm not surprised that it never went to his head, and that it still embarrasses him. Good call that the students would recognize him instantly, and be a bit star-struck. It's also a good call that Harry is autograph-tolerant around young children; they wouldn't understand why he might not want to.

Incidentally, this makes a nice contrast with Chloe's attitude; to her, Harry is just plain Harry, and even starts out with a black mark in her book.

Good touch of consistent characterization, actually, that Peeves would still rag on Harry with the same songs he used when Harry was a student. That's consistent with Peeves' behaviour toward Lupin in PA.

"Unfortu – [a]hem – well, in Mrs. Norris' case, it certainly seems that way."

[grin] So the general anti-Mrs. Norris sentiment in Gryffindor House starts at the top, I see.

Good call, that Hermione would retain the use of her maiden name professionally.

:) I'm glad that Hermione and Ron are still enjoying their arguments. Families are *supposed* to bait each other like that; that's what they're *for*. :) Wicked, that all it took was a knock at the door to set them off, and they basically forgot about the door itself (Percy had to open it, notice).

[I]"Harry!" he said, overjoyed to see someone not yelling.[/I]

Percy's a nice chap in this pre-OP AU, but he doesn't strike one as having the right attitude about friendly spats, does he? Seems very much in character for him that a free-wheeling argumentative relationship would frazzle his rule-bound soul.

Percy has *no* sense about names, but Penny obviously isn't doing much to stop him, so it's not all his fault, is it? (Good idea to eliminate the baby seat from the scene, by the way; it would make sense only if Percy had just flown in or something.)
The description of the baby could use work, I think. Words like "cute" and "adorable" don't help in visualizing the kid; we don't even know his gender from the description, but only once his name is given. Red-haired like Percy, for instance, or does he take after Penelope at all? Lively like his uncles, or quiet like his papa?

And why the French motif in the child's names? It's not as though his mother were Fleur, for example. Any reason? It calls attention to itself as it is but isn't explained that I can see.

[I]"I hope it doesn't get about what he does with the ill-behaved ones," whispered Ron with a grin.[/I]


If *I* were in Harry's place - unmarried and basically never had a serious relationship - I'd either keep my mouth closed about prodding any married people in the vicinity about having children, or I'd regret the words the instant they left my mouth. Ron and Hermione, certainly Ron, should've cleaned Harry's clock on that subject once he made himself a target by commenting. Percy, on the other hand, *has* got room to talk, so the line would seem better coming from him.

:) Neat, that even the baby is sitting there enjoying the argument, and that Ron and Hermione only just realized that they've been entertaining the audience for the last few minutes.

Incidentally, I'd have found it amusing to see Hermione have to cope with *something* unexpected, such as being pregnant with twins, just to see Ron get the upper hand in the argument sweepstakes for a bit. :)

I'm a bit disappointed in Harry, that he'd seriously consider leaving the child with the Dursleys and just forcing them to treat her better. (Post-OP, I hope he'd never do this.)

Good call, that Percy as a good father would immediately take against what the Dursleys did just as fast as anybody else, albeit expressing himself in a rather stuffy manner. Also good that he countered Harry's hesitation to take the child by pointing out that single parents are common, and that a five-year-old isn't too bad, considering.

"Downfall" should be "downside".

Since Harry is an Auror just after the war, would he really have a lot of free time? The Death Eaters would require mopping up for a long, long time, I imagine, and there are always random criminals roaming the world doing terrible things.


"I'm Chloe, and I don't like you."

[laughs out loud] Well, I like *you*, kid.

Nice touch, that she's a bit of a throwback to Lily physically in terms of eye colour.

Showing 1 to 3 of 3
If you enjoyed this work, take a moment to review the story. Your comments are their only payment.
This author is not accepting unsigned reviews.
Login for signed reviews.
Latest Stories
Thursday 24th May
Author: Melindaleo
Story: Some Cuts Leave Scars
Author: angelmorph
Story: A Different Boy Who Lived
Thursday 5th April
Author: Arnel
Story: Escape from Brextwistle Hall
Friday 16th March
Author: Caleb Nova
Story: Vis Insita
Thursday 4th January
Author: Sherylyn
Story: Hearts Afire
Saturday 14th January
Author: parakletos
Story: The Sins of the Fathers
Friday 9th December
Author: Author by Night
Story: Rufus Scrimgeour’s Annual Christmas Party
Friday 25th November
Author: Author by Night
Story: Full Circle
Saturday 15th October
Author: Author by Night
Story: It Opens
Wednesday 24th August
Author: Sovran
Story: Meaning of One, Part Two: Chambers and Secrets
Author: Author by Night
Story: This is the Life
Wednesday 27th April
Author: Author by Night
Story: I Solemnly Swear That I Am Up to No Good
Monday 7th March
Author: Author by Night
Story: Outside the Bubble
Friday 12th February
Author: parakletos
Story: Tiger Stripes
Wednesday 13th January
Author: Melindaleo
Story: These Cuts I Have
Tuesday 15th December
Author: Author by Night
Story: Beholders
Perfect Imagination: A Harry Potter Beta Reader directory.
Latest Art
Tuesday 20th January 2009
Artist: tripperfunster
Image: Lost Prophecy
Artist: tripperfunster
Image: Kitchen Argument
Artist: Hito
Image: Harry and Ginny
Saturday 10th January 2009
Artist: AgiVega
Image: Potter Cast Conquer Olympus I
Artist: GoldenSnitch33
Image: HP Art Project-Ch.23, OotP
Artist: mary-dreams
Image: Remus and Tonks - More Than Meets the Eyes
Wednesday 15th October 2008
Artist: bludgerbanger
Image: Wiinter Ginny and Hermione
Artist: bludgerbanger
Image: Bellatrix Lestrange
Artist: bludgerbanger
Image: The Silver Doe
Saturday 11th October 2008
Artist: Sanna
Image: Ginny Weasley and Harry Potter
Artist: GoldenSnitch33
Image: HP Art Project
Wednesday 6th August 2008
Artist: GoldenSnitch33
Image: Holyhead Ginny
Artist: bludgerbanger
Image: Ginny Sneaks Into the Broomshed
Artist: bludgerbanger
Image: Trio-Hats
Artist: bludgerbanger
Image: Notorious Mass Murderer
Friday 13th June 2008
Artist: AgiVega
Image: Lily For Ever
Artist: roby_boh
Image: 1st Year Luna and Ginny
Friday 6th June 2008
Artist: Rae F
Image: A Family Christmas

Help keep Phoenixsong Running - Donate