Flash07 Tuesday 29th March 2011 13:57 | Consequences of the Heart |
I would have told Remus to stick his bracelet up his >>>>. If I was Harry, I would told them to stick it. No one in this story has the right to do this to him. They can take away school, but he can take away their lives so let D decide which he prefers. My BP exploded after this chapter as to who these people think they are especially Remus, I never thought about Harry before, Lupin. |
kmackone Monday 9th February 2009 07:56 | Consequences of the Heart |
After everything that Harry has already suffered by being forced to be a slave to the muggle and the wizarding world it is wrong, across the board, to make Harry wear an enchanted bracelet to force him to have feelings for Ginny. Your version of Ginny is so out in the AU universe as to be unlovable. She should be thoroughly spanked and expelled and sent to Beauxbatons, so Harry can move on with his life.
Forced love is no better than what Romilda Vane did with the love potion. This story is unacceptable to me. I will not finish it. I'm sure you'll have them all happy together at the end and everyone will love it. Everyone but me.
I believe in Harry's right to control his life, as much as possible. This scenerio is a travesty. I believe in Harry and Ginny being together, but by their own choices not those of diseased and befuddled old quacks like your Dumbledore. Your Lupin is a traitor to Harry. Lupin should stand up For Harry against anything anyone tries to do to him, not be his Lord and Master.
If I was in that cituation I would literally shove the bracelet up Lupin's arse. Harry is the wronged party in this. He should not be punished at all let alone to have Ginny, the unreasable bitch made to be his minder.
It's really sad to see another story where the premise is everyone has the right to abuse Harry without a logical reason, except he's Harry and it's conveient and fun to mess with him.
On a scale of 1-10 I give it a 0. Harry deserves better. |
Prongs739 Monday 25th August 2008 16:59 | Consequences of the Heart |
Well, I wonder if that is the start of something better between the two of them. They did have one very powerful battle, what with knocking Snape off of his feet with two simple spells.
|
harrysnotgoingtodiein7 Wednesday 18th July 2007 12:55 | Consequences of the Heart |
i was rotflol when Molly said Ginny would be going to Beaxbatons.
This is funny, im betting in the next chapter they will |
noylj Saturday 29th July 2006 22:02 | Consequences of the Heart |
I am rereading. I still say Harry has the worse of it. I would be happy to watch Ginny sweat as I brought out water and food... |
ImmortalPhoenix Monday 17th April 2006 16:46 | Consequences of the Heart |
Sorry for the double post. I also forgot to mention a theory I have before I read the rest of the story and either prove it right or wrong. I think that they were placed together 1. because Dumbledore knows they are meant to be together and 2. Firenze had to of mentioned more than that. I think FIrenze or someone told him {Dumbledore} that they needed to be together... like they needed to be in school together because they were going to need to work to gether to do something with the war... I dunno just a hteory and I hope im right... anyway Im on to the next chapter!!!
Kortnee |
ImmortalPhoenix Monday 17th April 2006 16:41 | Consequences of the Heart |
Wow I don't even want to stop for a review so that means I absolutely love it so far.
Kortnee |
ImmortalPhoenix Monday 17th April 2006 16:41 | Consequences of the Heart |
Wow I don't even want to stop for a review so that means I absolutely love it so far.
Kortnee |
pixiellie Saturday 13th November 2004 21:55 | Consequences of the Heart |
Hee. They’re
grounded. A summer full of work sounds
pretty harsh to me as Harry’s punishment, until you realize that he spends his
summers pretty much working anyway, the Weasley’s will at least let him outside
and feed him, and, well, he did hex a teacher, and ignore his head of
house. So, I can accept. Grin The catch was he was stuck with
Ginny. In my house, my Dad kept the
fighting kids separated. Hmmm. I wonder….Hee (I tend to review as the chapter goes, I hope they make sense to
you. If not feel free to let me know)
I really really really like that Molly calls Ginny on her
insensitive behavior. The same day as
Sirius dies- come on! (You’re going to
have to work not get me and Harry to forgive her…) But this scene went along
way towards me seeing her side. She
knows she was wrong, and she mourns both for Harry and Sirius.
Ok. I’m feeling
sorry for Ginny now. No one should have
Molly Weasley mad at them for a summer, or have to miss dinner. Plus, she’ll be Harry’s servant. The Weasley pride will be up in arms over
this.
Great job of capturing a teenaged girl’s love of verbal
italics and dramatic statements. (I
should know, I’m still fighting the instinct to underline every review.)
Grin.
(Just a note Ewww over the Vernon moment. Oh, and Remus and Petunia, double Eww.)
I like the contrast of Remus pointing out that Harry and
Ginny’s friendship never being the same and Harry acknowledging that, and Ginny
still calling Harry a brat and trying to shift more of the blame. They seem to be approaching the punishment
from very different directions in a way.
Maybe it’s that Ginny never really felt like one of Harry’s
friends.
Nice foreshadowing that Firenze sees their continued
presence (and friendship?) important to the war against Voldimort. Again, they have to be so together? Hmmm….
I’m not sure I like the idea of monitoring bracelets. A person can’t help the way they feel, and
it seems cruel to add a type of corporal punishment for emotions. As long as they carry out their chores, that
should have satisfied the terms. But,
for the sake of the story, I can accept them, and see how they come into play
in the future.
Poor Ginny. I don’t
blame her for holding on to her anger.
(You are doing a wonderful job in getting me to empathize with both
characters. My sympathy has yo yo’ed
back and forth- both for Harry and Ginny.
That’s hard for a writer to do!)
Hee. What a
difference a talk with Mum can do.
She’s flirting, and getting a reaction, even if Harry isn’t sure that’s
what’s happening yet. I like that she
began talking to him, reminding him of the person he began to be friends with
earlier in the year.
I felt a little sad though, that Harry was that exhausted,
and looked for Ginny, and she didn’t appear.
I liked this chapter, and you have continued to create a
unique situation. The best part has
been your ability to express what our favorite couple is feeling. You have a gift for leaving things hinted,
but unsaid. I look forward to the next
chapter.
As always, pass along my appreciation to your betas, the
grammar and spelling were terrific.
Take some of those thanks for yourself as well. You take time and effort to share with
strangers, and we thank you. Pixie
|
Sunday 14th November 2004 21:31 | Consequences of the Heart (Author Response) |
Whew. Another marathon review. I like your review style -
reviewing as you read. It make perfect sense and I won't
discourage you at all.
The punishments were the hardest bits of this story to write. I
found myself waffling between being too hard on both of them and being
too lenient. In the end, I hope I found a good balance.
The bracelets were a late addition to the plot, but add another level
of complexity to the plot - giving the reader another way to see what's
going on in H&G's heads. They also play a part in a future
sequel (or two). Never underestimate the power of sentimental
attachment to jewelery.
|
Cera Wednesday 13th October 2004 19:40 | Consequences of the Heart |
Phew... this was a long one.
I like that you've written both Harry and Ginny was strong personalilties. It isn't unrealistic that they would argue like siblings (well... not really like sibling.. but you know )
"Sleep that night came late and her dreams were filled with visions of Harry suspended from the ceiling, covered in enraged Bowtruckles, or Harry pinned between a Chimaera and a Blast-ended-Screwt at the bottom of a Doxie infested canyon, or Harry naked and covered in chocolate...."
This was a great part! The punishments were inventive, and the last bit made me crack up.
Great chapter!
Sarah |
Keytobias5 Wednesday 15th September 2004 11:15 | Consequences of the Heart |
This very nice. I can see where this is heading and I look foreward to the next chappie.
~Toby |
brad Wednesday 15th September 2004 02:06 | Consequences of the Heart |
Cute. A bit contrived, but cute.
Are the adults seriously trying to arrange a romance here? Has
Firenze given them more details about exactly WHY the couple have to
continue attending Hogwarts? Will a violinist be showing up for
their next dinner under the stars?
The Firenze advice was, indeed, a very good touch, adding an extra
dimension/undercurrent for we readers to ruminate about. Hmmm ...
is romantic love part of the 'power the dark lord has not' with which
Harry will win the day? Good one.
That bit about Ron & Hermione snogging for a year - spoken to Mrs.
Weasely of all people - was a surprise, as this is supposed to be
coming straight after the end of OotP. Have I missed something
(along with Harry)? And will Ron be showing up to help/watch
Harry perform his next task?
Looking forward to more!
|
Wednesday 15th September 2004 02:06 | Consequences of the Heart (Author Response) |
Ooh. I'd answer but I'm afraid I'd incriminate myself. Of course it's contrived! It's an A/U! :D
Ron's got some parts to play in future chapters, so we'll see more of
Ginny's infuriating older brother. Along those lines, Hermione
'pops' in for a visit as well. Around July 31st, I believe.
Thanks for the great review! Keep them coming.
|
p0tterfan Wednesday 15th September 2004 00:35 | Consequences of the Heart |
Promising start. Looking forward to the rest. |
Kokopelli Tuesday 14th September 2004 20:51 | Consequences of the Heart |
Actually, there's a lot of plots that in the abstract are just terrible, but the story is wonderful. Delylah's Deadly Deception is a real oddball plot - Harry fakes his death and comes back to school to live as a Slytherin in disguise - Puh-Leez! That being said, that story is terrific, no matter how lame the plot synopsis might be.
Harry and Ginny torque each other off to the point of a dangerous duel. As punishment they are forced to work together until . . . .well, you get the point. Some plots, in synopsis form, inhale vigorously with lots of lip action.
This story, however, shows lots and lots of promise, until the last chapter, when it goes completely out of control, but that's not Michaels fault either.
J |
Kelleypen Tuesday 14th September 2004 19:56 | Consequences of the Heart |
wonderful. this is working really well. I can't wait for the next chapter. Kelley |
Kokopelli Tuesday 14th September 2004 19:40 | Consequences of the Heart |
Okay, you've made it this far - take a deep breath. Okay, now, let it out. The story gets much, much better after this chapter, keep reading.
MrIntel (Michael) and I have been trading barbs, bad jokes, double entendres and stories for several months now, and when he outlined this story I thought to myself "gag me with a spoon - this is going to be a terrible story." But because I'm an exceptionally tender and sensitive guy, I didn't tell him that, so he shipped me the first two chapters anyway.
Michael writes - dilligently. His goal is to write 1000 words a day - I don't know how often he misses his goal, but I know that when I send him an e-mail at lunchtime (my lunchtime, not his) listing my gripes, questions and suggestions for one of his stories, more often than not by bedtime (my bedtime) he's sent me a new revision to the chapter.
This story has taken shape with a lot of work on Michael's part, putting up with my rants, lame suggestions and ribald comments. Some people take him to task for his characterization, but I think he's spot on with this one - there are no characterizations here that can't be defended with references to canon.
Sit back and enjoy the show - you're in for a treat.
Has Kokopelli ever steered you wrong?
J |
Tuesday 14th September 2004 19:40 | Consequences of the Heart (Author Response) |
Wow... I think you may have actually made me blush there,
John. Such unabashed endorsements are as common as a tornado in
Utah; they happen, but once a decade.
"Exceptionally sensetive and tender", eh? You've been letting your fangirls inflate your ego again, haven't you?
Although I'm surprised to know that you thought this was a horrible
plot idea and that it panned out anyway, despite my attempts at
characterization.
Speaking of which, I want to let anyone who's reading this to know that
I'm the only one to blame if you disagree with how my characters act in
this story. This is how I see Harry, Ginny, and company behaving
given the scenario I presented. Like John said, I can defend my
position with canon, though many might not agree with me. That's
okay - it's what makes the world a great place to live in.
|