Authors: - A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P R S T V W X Y Z

Reviews For Magic Within, Magic Without by St Margarets

DaniKay
Saturday 28th March 2009 17:49
Magic Within, Magic Without
Well that's got to be the most interesting journey in a forest eh?
Lmao LOVED the bed scene! The Arm Menace! And then there's the Hair Mask! Be afraid, be very afraid *bursts out into giggles*
DaniKay
Monday 30th March 2009 08:30Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)
Sharing a bed *sounds* so romantic - but reality is not always the case.
gymnastgal19
Saturday 12th January 2008 09:40
Magic Within, Magic Without
wow... im guessing that that jarvey knows something and that cat from the last chapter is an angimus? sorta like wormtail i guess...
that well sounds interesting... i bet that there is more to it and will become important later on in the story.
aunt martha told them to stay in the woods too...
VegHindu101
Thursday 27th December 2007 07:07
Magic Within, Magic Without
So I've read this story several times and I have 'sympathy' for poor Harry with his nightmares while Ginny sleeps on top of him.... *sigh* stupid boy!
Friday 28th December 2007 17:11Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)
I was a cruel author, wasn't I? LOL Ah, well, it worked out in the end. I'm glad you liked this story well enough to read it more than once. That makes my day. Thanks.
r3d_umbrella
Tuesday 1st May 2007 16:31
Magic Within, Magic Without
Hey, I love how this is going so far. I'm very curious about that feather--and this aunt of Ginny's; I do assume she's involved with everything? I know this story's finished, so I might drop in a few times to comment before I get to the end.
Tuesday 1st May 2007 16:35Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)
Oh, yes - do let me know what strikes you as you read. It's an old story of mine, so it's fun to re-live it with a new reader. And yes, Aunt Martha is very important in this story.
GryffindorDragon
Monday 2nd October 2006 16:46
Magic Within, Magic Without
'Ten minutes later, the arm thumped her in the ear.' -- -- Harry the bed hog; poor Ginny . 'she never dreamed the worst horror would be the Arm That Wouldn't Sleep' -- .
So Ginny is something special ... opens the fountain (which Harry couldn't see) and is recognized by the old cow ( ). But I think your last chapter title is a bit off (unless Aunt Martha isn't a Weasley but only married a Weasley?)
daniel_r_crazy22
Friday 9th June 2006 13:39
Magic Within, Magic Without
That was very odd. But was very good. Harry's core is a feather, and snidgets are cool. I would be proud, but I see why Ginny is not. I like it, hopefully it keeps being like this.
Black Vengeance
Tuesday 2nd August 2005 12:41
Magic Within, Magic Without
Aw, poor Ginny - Harry was a bit mean at the beginning! :-( I like your idea of Ginny's wand coming from the Golden Snidget - that's quite an original idea. Your writing is still brilliant and I'm intrigued!
Tuesday 2nd August 2005 18:40Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)
Well, I would say that Harry is a bit frustrated at this point - waking up with a beautiful girl drapped all over you would have to be difficult for a 16 year old boy.  That's why he was being so off-putting to Ginny - but he manages to put up with her bad mood later, so I'd say they were even.
kensai
Tuesday 14th December 2004 13:24
Magic Within, Magic Without
I enjoy how you are building a stable framework for the story.
Eressea
Friday 10th December 2004 15:41
Magic Within, Magic Without

  I love your style!  Everything is so unique.  Like the well. 

Bring and Fly
Thursday 18th November 2004 04:56
Magic Within, Magic Without

Ah, the Arm With a Mind of its Own... yup-that sounds about right! And I think you gauged Ginny's reaction very realistically. I enjoyed the spat when Harry came back into the room and their exchange about Snape.

I do like Aunt Martha. She reminds me of someone I knew as a child, especially with all the ornaments! having them discuss Harry and Ginny as though they couldn't hear them was just brilliant.

"Try to enjoy yourselves today," Aunt Martha said with a gleam in her eye. "Although it's not a good sign if you can't get along in bed." You'd think I'd have learned not to eat/drink whilst at the computer by now, wouldn't you? That was so funny and unexpected that I burst out laughing!

Interested and curious about Ginny's dowsing abilities, as well as her wand. Harry does have this knack for opening his mouth and saying the first thing that comes into his head, doesn't he. *sigh* he's young, he'll learn.

Friday 19th November 2004 14:04Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)

I think Aunt Martha is a composite of all the old ladies from my youth as well.  I would have loved talking mugs and figurines when I was kid!

blinieldar
Tuesday 16th November 2004 09:33
Magic Within, Magic Without
Great Story so far! update soon please
fsecada
Monday 15th November 2004 01:39
Magic Within, Magic Without

I really try not to force the humor.  It's a fine line sometimes.  Still, JKR made OotP bearable for Harry and for the readers with humor - so I try to keep that in mind. 

And there's nothing wrong with mirth, in any story, no matter how dark. After all, if you can't laugh, in the midst of sorrow, the only thing left is tears, right?

ViviRed75
Sunday 14th November 2004 19:46
Magic Within, Magic Without
That was wonderful. It kept me grinning the entire time. I enjoyed how you are developing Ginny's character and how Harry reacts to her remarks. Also, I liked your technique in the first chapter where you just jumped straight to the action and didn't dally with what everyone did/is doing in the summer. It made it much more captivating and I can't wait to read more! Write more, please.
Sunday 14th November 2004 20:22Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)
I started this story so many different ways - and then I realized that I only cared about what was happening to H/G at that moment.  Once I let myself write about what interested me - it became so much easier. 
ninkenate
Sunday 14th November 2004 19:39
Magic Within, Magic Without
I loved the bed scene. Are you sure you didn't model it after my husband's sleeping patterns? I certainly can sympathize with Ginny and her problems slepping with him. It was hilarious. I believe there's more behind Ginny's wand than what we know. I can't wait to find out.

I noticed Harry is quite protective of Ginny and determined to find out more about the situation. He really doesn't want the Malfoy's to get their hands on her. That's a sign. I hope Ginny notices.
Sunday 14th November 2004 20:18Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)

As the world's lightest sleeper - I write from experience! 

Ginny notices a lot but is not letting herself think about anything - because she has given up on him - for now.

fsecada
Sunday 14th November 2004 05:48
Magic Within, Magic Without

St. Margaret, in every one of your stories, in every chapter, you make me laugh. Sometimes even in the most heartbreaking scenes, there's something funny that's said, or someone makes light of their tears, and I just have to smile.

This line just jumped out at me.

She was never going to sleep as long as this bed hog only gave her six inches of mattress

So familiar. I just had to laugh. I was all set for some real fluff (and perhaps a trip to the broom closet  ), and instead it was a summer-camp moment.

Just a little something extra I look forward to, above and beyond your wonderful stories that just draw me in, your excellent dialogue, and the 'realness' of your characterization of Harry and Ginny.

Sunday 14th November 2004 20:24Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)
I really try not to force the humor.  It's a fine line sometimes.  Still, JKR made OotP bearable for Harry and for the readers with humor - so I try to keep that in mind. 
huffboy36
Saturday 13th November 2004 19:17
Magic Within, Magic Without
Well, this is coming along splendidly.  Captivating, attention getting, and just enough fluff to satisfy my sweet tooth.  Please, please continue.  
Saturday 13th November 2004 21:49Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)
Oh, I'm having a hard time restraining myself with the fluff.  Still, to be realistic, it's going to take them a while to satisfy my sweet tooth!
thehopefulGinnyPotter
Saturday 13th November 2004 16:42
Magic Within, Magic Without
I absolutely love your stories and this one is no exception. This is great. Update soon.
p0tterfan
Saturday 13th November 2004 15:16
Magic Within, Magic Without
The first 'bed test' - good indeed.  Good backstory you seem to have built as well.  You've gotten the H/G interactions down pat :)

Good job!  Looking forward to the next chapter ...
Saturday 13th November 2004 21:47Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)
There is a bit more back story, I'm afraid - but hopefully it will be interesting.
XiaoXiao
Saturday 13th November 2004 02:59
Magic Within, Magic Without

The reality of the bed situation was great--they didn't immediately cuddle up and "feel like they came home".  It was funny, of course, too.

I liked their adventures in the woods, especially knowing the parts of Ginny's wand.  V. cute.

Saturday 13th November 2004 21:47Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)

Well - even at home you sometimes just want to sleep uninterrupted!   That was a fun scene to write.

Delani
Saturday 13th November 2004 02:50
Magic Within, Magic Without

heh, loved this:

"discussed it amongst themselves until the next Interesting Thing happened"

Capitalizing Interesting Things; quite clever!  Same applies here as to the previous chapter; awesome!

Delani

Robert Owen
Saturday 13th November 2004 00:43
Magic Within, Magic Without

I can see why Ginny hates to visit!  "The attack of the Arm!"  What till the twins find out!

 

Robert

Pugpal
Friday 12th November 2004 21:09
Magic Within, Magic Without
 Cool!
mary-v
Friday 12th November 2004 18:29
Magic Within, Magic Without

And I also forgot to mention, I love the ideas you use in this story. Like the magical items. and the way you portrayed Aunt Martha. The old mentality and such! And I think you could fill in the blank: please ________ soon! lol

~Maria~

Saturday 13th November 2004 21:46Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)
I'm afraid at my house the blank would be filled with - cook dinner, do laundry, vaccum.  LOL.  Updating sounds like more fun!  Don't worry, I have another chapter ready to go and another almost ready.  I have to take a break at Thanksgiving - but I'll be dilligent updating regularly.  I have some fluff to look forward to!
mary-v
Friday 12th November 2004 18:26
Magic Within, Magic Without

And another brilliant chapter! Excellent work! Although I get the impression that the names you use are actors' names. Like Jason Biggs and Anne Hathaway.lol, well, please update really soon!

~Maria~

 

Kelleypen
Friday 12th November 2004 17:33
Magic Within, Magic Without
Very nice.  The Weasley Aunt is a real old poop.  Some things remind me of your last--sexy ankles,  magical things asking about Ginny's betrothal yet--it works well. I hope they find some lunch, and maybe some romantic intrigue. Kelley
Saturday 13th November 2004 21:40Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)
Great Aunt Martha has been in two of my stories - I guess I was meant to write about her finally!  I think you find her more sympathetic as time goes on.  She has quite an interesting story herself.
Mr. Intel
Friday 12th November 2004 16:45
Magic Within, Magic Without
Another well-written, wonderfully crafted chapter.  At the end, I thought to myself, "was it only 5600 words?"  Your descriptions are top-notch and as we slowly slide into the plot, rich with well-thought background information, I find myself desperate for more.  I want to know more about Ginny.  I need to know more about why she's special and for what purpose Lord Twisted-Knickers wants her for.  Mostly, I want to read the slow build-up to when Harry and Ginny snog each other senseless. 
Friday 12th November 2004 16:53Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)

Do I have a snogging scenario for you!  It's all in my mind - and I can't wait to write it!  But like you said, it will be a slow-build up!

amulder
Friday 12th November 2004 16:05
Magic Within, Magic Without
Interesting snippets, and lots of fascinating twists and turns.     I like what you write!

- a cow named Hera that runs off a lot, and was startled to see Ginny.

- A Jarvey that claims the cat is an animagus.    (Hmm, the hp lexicon claims Jarvey's only issue rude phrases and insults.  How is that an
insult?)  So what about Pamela then?

- A mysterious well, and a stone circle on a hill?

I *did* think they might talk more about the bed.  For instance I would have thought that Harry might have explained why he fell asleep instead of staying up to discuss "the arrangements" with her.

Aunt Martha claims "The Weasley Woment have always been tall".    Right.  *WHAT* Weasley women!?    Ginny is the first one in generations.  In the last chapter Ginny tells Harry that Martha was the first in over
a century.  So, who, precisely, is Martha talking about?  Or is she just being abrasive?     It would have been a good place for Harry or Ginny to
comment.  But I suppose Ginny is so used to being cowed by this woman that she isn't thinking about arguing.

Agree with Kokopelli though, Ginny *does* seem a bit on the quiet side in this fiction.  Sure, she's in shock from the abduction, but she was
a ball of fire in OOTP.     There's certainly some internal fire, but it seems all under tight reign.

Y'know, Harry really is growing up and maturing.  He didn't make a single crack about Ginny's "nice ankles".  <snort>


thanks for sharing.  I look forward to the next installment.
...art
Friday 12th November 2004 16:52Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)

The Jarvey and the cat obviously have a problem with each other!

They will talk more about the bed - but not for a long time to come.  It is a little too fresh in their minds - esp. after Aunt Martha made those insinuations.

JKR never said that the Weasley women have always been thin on the ground.  Poor Aunt Martha probably knew lots of Weasley women growing up - and then --nothing for a hundred years - and then the next Weasley girl is short!

Ginny has been too well-brought up by Molly to contradict her elderly relative.  However she does have a heart-to-heart later on and discovers why Aunt Martha says these things.  A lot of it is competition women put each other through and don't even realize they are doing it.

I see this situation I have put her in - what she perceives as a hostile environment - as analogous to her first year at Hogwarts.  Ginny has always had a brother(s) or parents with her.  This is a first for her as far as we know.  So I do think she would be lessy chatty.  Plus, she's in a really bad mood during this chapter!  That will change though.

And Harry would never say anything to embarrass Ginny - esp. about her ankles - although I can bet that got him thinking . . .

All great comments!  Hope I answered them to your satisfaction.  Or hopefully the story will in the fullness of time.

 

Ima Quidditch Fan
Friday 12th November 2004 14:53
Magic Within, Magic Without

Building a mystery...  love it!  I am so curious as to the direction of the story, can't wait for more.  The well has me a bit confused, but I suppose it has something to do with why LV wants her.  While she can protect herself, I am glad Harry is with her too. I think they make a good team.

I laughed so hard at 'the Arm' and the situation...  you are too funny!  At the same time my heart goes to Ginny with her Aunt. 

Harry, in my opinion, has been a good friend and supportive of Ginny.  I cross my fingers for love to bloom.

 

Friday 12th November 2004 16:55Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)
It's summer!  It's H/G!  Of course love will bloom!
Aberforth's Avatar
Friday 12th November 2004 14:10
Magic Within, Magic Without

This chapter is priceless.  I loved Aunt Martha, and enjoyed the fact that even her Toby jugs knew that Ginny had shapely ankles.  Poor Ginevra.  Nothing is going smoothly for her today, is it?  Still, for us Gentle Readers, the scenes between she and Harry were enchanting. 

 

In two chapters you have written well-crafted and suspenseful action scenes and some wonderfully intimate quiet conversations between Harry and Ginny.  I am thoroughly enjoying your new tale.

Iris
Friday 12th November 2004 14:08
Magic Within, Magic Without
"the Arm That Wouldn't Sleep"

a great chapter...looking forward to more.

~Iris
Kokopelli
Friday 12th November 2004 14:03
Magic Within, Magic Without
This is an altogether interesting (and delightful) exercise in writing HG.

The arm - beware the arm!

A problem I have in writing Fan Fic is getting Ginny just right.  I had a lengthy fan-fic going before OotP and had a pale weepy Ginny that was defined mainly by her unrequited love for Harry.  OotP blew me out of the water in many ways.  This fic seems to be siding more on the side of pre-OotP Ginny - she's not as brash and bold at OotP Ginny.

I'm fascinated as to where you're taking the story, however.

JEC
Friday 12th November 2004 16:38Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)

Ginny is kind of a contradiction in OotP - she takes charge of the stink sap episode, names Dumbledore's Army etc . . . But there is still a part of her that looks up to Harry during a crisis.  I'm thinking of when her father is injured.  At that time she enters Dumbledore's office and she asks Harry and not Ron what's happening.  When Ron is being strangled by the brains, she screams at Harry to do something.  Yes, she is independent - not accepting Luna's help, teaching herself to fly, etc . . . Yet, she reveals herself to Harry in these telling ways.  That, to me, seems an important way to build true intimacy - which is to know each others weaknesses as well as strengths.

I have the luxury in a longer fic. to show more of how I see Ginny because I'm allowed to delve into her thoughts.  (which may contradict some of her actions)  She may not be canon!Ginny - but then we haven't gotten to know canon!Ginny too well yet.

Penny Lane
Friday 12th November 2004 13:23
Magic Within, Magic Without

Well.  Ginny was a bit of a Miss Cranky Pants in this chapter, wasn't she?     It's nice for a change to read a fic where she's the one in a bad mood, and Harry's the one being calm and reasonable(ish).   

I loved the anxiety clock.  You've got a lot of nice little touches like that in this story.

Friday 12th November 2004 16:29Magic Within, Magic Without (Author Response)
She was having the ultimate bad hair day - which everyone deserves now and then.  I don't think it's fair that Ginny has to be perfect to win Harry's admiration.  Like all moods, this won't last!  And like all moods, it's not very logical.
snowbear96
Friday 12th November 2004 13:06
Magic Within, Magic Without
funny and sweet