Authors: - A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P R S T V W X Y Z

Reviews For A Halloween to Remember by melray1228

gymnastgal19
Monday 29th October 2007 14:32
A Halloween to Remember
awww!!! I loved this!!! those robes were ingenuis!
pyromain
Wednesday 12th September 2007 07:01
A Halloween to Remember
perfect, what more can I say.
Ashley06
Thursday 29th December 2005 18:35
A Halloween to Remember

LOL that was hilarious!! Good job.

Cera
Saturday 20th November 2004 15:14
A Halloween to Remember

This was a really sweet, funny story!

My favourite line was,

"Ginny, I can't believe you punched that guy at the end!"

Heh.  Sure sounds like Ginny.  The prank was hilarious too.  The last costume being, of course, my favourite.

Well done!

Friday 26th November 2004 21:03A Halloween to Remember (Author Response)
Thanks!  I'm glad that you enjoyed it!  I actually borrowed the punch from my normally calm and mild mother-in-law.  She actually punched a guy that jumped out at her at a haunted house.  The family is STILL laughing about that one years after it happened!
Stormdelver
Saturday 20th November 2004 11:54
A Halloween to Remember

Wonderful little story- I know it is a stand-alone- but it could be the beginning of a longer story as well- Oh well just pushing for anothor H/G fic. Love Snape's robes. Great story- consider at least a couple of more chapters- the "I love you" was very abrupt and without any lead in or out- needs a bit more explaination.

 

Friday 26th November 2004 21:05A Halloween to Remember (Author Response)
I appreciate your comments.  I thought about the abrubtness of the "I love you" as I wrote it, but being the incurable romantic that I am, I decided to leave it in.
brios
Friday 19th November 2004 19:58
A Halloween to Remember
 funny and sweet, the way I like them best. 
Friday 26th November 2004 21:06A Halloween to Remember (Author Response)
Thanks - it's always nice to hear that someone enjoys your work!
Antonia East
Thursday 18th November 2004 16:50
A Halloween to Remember
The changing costume was inspired, and the parcel from the twins was a nice touch.  'Is it a bird, is it a plane, no, it's SUPERSNAPE!
Friday 26th November 2004 21:07A Halloween to Remember (Author Response)
I was rather proud of that scene myself.  It took me a bit longer to write that scene than some of the others because I was laughing so hard. 
DADAGinny
Thursday 18th November 2004 13:35
A Halloween to Remember
That was great!  The prank on Snape was the best!  Hillarious!


Friday 26th November 2004 21:09A Halloween to Remember (Author Response)
Thanks!  I thought of a few other costumes, too, but I decided that Snape couldn't handle more than that. 
Bring and Fly
Thursday 18th November 2004 04:13
A Halloween to Remember

Other than the   +    =  ness ,(which I'm a sucker for!) I did enjoy    getting his come-uppance!!

I know I said I liked it when I first read it, but I'll say it again and I'm around for idea tossing when ever you like!

Cara         Baffy

Friday 26th November 2004 21:10A Halloween to Remember (Author Response)
Thanks again for being such a fabulous Beta!    You were a tremendous help, and I look forward to sharing more stories with you in the future.
XiaoXiao
Thursday 18th November 2004 01:01
A Halloween to Remember
Very cute.  I especially liked the part where Snape turned into Harry!
Friday 26th November 2004 21:16A Halloween to Remember (Author Response)
Thanks!  I knew that the Harry costume would be the one to send dear old Snape over the edge!
Ima Quidditch Fan
Thursday 18th November 2004 00:21
A Halloween to Remember
Very sweet, and quite funny!
Friday 26th November 2004 21:16A Halloween to Remember (Author Response)
Thanks! 
Robert Owen
Wednesday 17th November 2004 22:23
A Halloween to Remember

Huge guffaws!  Love the self transfiguring costume and Snape as Superman! 

 

Robert

Friday 26th November 2004 21:17A Halloween to Remember (Author Response)
Thanks!  When the idea for this story came to me, the costume was what arrived in my mind first.  I knew that I HAD to include it in the story.