Authors: - A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P R S T V W X Y Z

Reviews For The Thaw by Jacynthe

mwinter
Tuesday 27th January 2015 13:01
The Thaw
To short could do with a whole other chapter or 2. Nice.
Dad
Wednesday 1st April 2009 08:14
The Thaw
Had to read this after the last one. Ginny was great. Get back to your third story after tea.
hpnopart
Friday 7th November 2008 03:50
The Thaw
Wow! That was a well written story. I really loved it's tone. I am glad I found it! It is a pity you haven't written in ages.
drummersgirl
Sunday 2nd November 2008 18:11
The Thaw
I know this has been out for awhile, but I just found it and I have to say one of the stories that has the most canon like harry and ginnyI've ever read! Great job
majolie
Saturday 1st November 2008 18:08
The Thaw
Wow - fabulous. I am loving this story hugely. I wish it went on and on. You've got one more story posted here and I am hoping it's much longer.
gymnastgal19
Thursday 11th September 2008 15:44
The Thaw
chiantiqueen
Tuesday 15th January 2008 03:22
The Thaw
Great story! I love the part about Weasleys being like dragons!
gymnastgal19
Tuesday 9th October 2007 16:35
The Thaw
this is an awesome story. amazing how Ginny and Harry just confessed to liking each other and they are already talking about marriage and stuff lol.
Monday 29th October 2007 07:21The Thaw (Author Response)
Thanks! (and while they ma just have got round to talking about relationships, you can bet that she, at least, has been thinking it through for a good long while.)
TrainzStoffe
Thursday 4th October 2007 17:01
The Thaw
You're really serious, aren't you? This is just a one-chapter story? I can't believe it... because, in some ways, it really doesn't read like that. It could very well have been a prologue to a multi-chaptered story. But in other ways, it is very much just one chapter long. There are just more things happening in this chapter than a usual multi-chaptered chapter (whoa...), and much faster.
That being said, I'm actually disappointed (and this is the point I started to make in the beginning...). I thought I had found my next long-time read story here, because I really like it. I like your writing style and use of words - it's different than most fanfic (or even writing in general, as far as I know), and it's a good different. I don't know how to say it... It feels to me like a language that is good, with a wide vocabulary and well practiced. A language that could very well be pretentious, but it's not. It's like it knows it's good, but doesn't have to show off.
The story is good too, very good, and I would love to read this as the beginning of an epic kind of story. I'll just have to imagine it myself instead, I guess.
Thank you for a great story!
Monday 29th October 2007 07:25The Thaw (Author Response)
Glad you liked it, and yes this really is all there is. I did play around with a brief sequel at one point, but it wasn't working. As you work your way through the stories on this site, meanwhile, you will see that there are many fine writers here in a variety of styles.

Happy reading.
nicole_celtic
Wednesday 20th June 2007 11:07
The Thaw
That was really good
Tuesday 26th June 2007 10:10The Thaw (Author Response)
I'm glad you liked it (and honored to get your first review!)
pyromain
Thursday 7th June 2007 13:32
The Thaw
I really liked this story it was bold and I enjoyed it. This isn't quite the ginny manners I had pictured for my self.
Monday 11th June 2007 09:55The Thaw (Author Response)
Thanks for reviewing, and I'm glad you liked my portrait of a better, bolder Ginny. Sometimes, a girl just has to take charge if anything is to get done at all.
daniel_r_crazy22
Thursday 11th January 2007 18:25
The Thaw
Aww. I liked that. That was very cute. And I like the part


"What I'm about to say … please believe me when I tell you that it has absolutely nothing to do with fact that my hand is … where it is right now, OK?"

"Absolutely."

"What I want you to know is … I'm really, really glad you're on my side."


Love it! Very well written
Friday 9th February 2007 02:44The Thaw (Author Response)
Thanks! This was my first story ever, and it's alsways nice to know that people are still reading it.
Miri
Tuesday 9th January 2007 13:54
The Thaw
I am sooo glad that I found this fantastic story (by way of the story of the week for this week--I always check out the author's profile to see their other works).

I'm also rather glad that I read this after HBP. I did enjoy the 6th book but I must admit that if I had read your version of Harry's arrival at the Burrow before JKR's, I might well have found cannon a bit bland ;-) Now I'm off to read your other stories.

Long Live the Quartet!
Friday 9th February 2007 02:42The Thaw (Author Response)
Thanks so much. This is the first story I ever posted, and I must admit to a sentimental fondness for it. As for the business of blandness ... let's just say that, unlike Jo Rowling, I don't have a censor (sorry, editor) from Scholastic Books reading over my shoulder ...
rdprice29
Thursday 5th October 2006 21:24
The Thaw
This was very, very sweet! I am here from Melindaleo's gem list, and I agree, this story is a GEM!

Wonderful job, I really, really enjoyed the interaction between Harry and Ginny. Great Job!
Saturday 7th October 2006 09:43The Thaw (Author Response)
Oh hooray, someone is still reading this! It's the very first story I ever posted and I'm still ridiculously proud of it. Thanks for reviewing.
red5
Thursday 23rd March 2006 17:13
The Thaw
"Do boys even get a vote in these things?"

"Don't be silly."

omg. what a great line and a great story. i found yours from Melindaleo's gems link, and have never been more happy! wonderfully written, looking forward to others! cheers!
Tuesday 28th March 2006 20:35The Thaw (Author Response)
Thanks! The Thaw is probably destined to be a one-shot story, but I had a great time writing it and am always happy when others tell me that they enjoyed reading it. For a rather different perspective on Harry and Ginny, meanwhile, stay tuned for updates of the Ravenclaw stories right here on PS.net.
Hoss
Monday 27th February 2006 09:37
The Thaw
That was the 3 or 4 time I've read this fic. and I enjoy it more then I can say!!! Thanks so much.
Wednesday 1st March 2006 09:19The Thaw (Author Response)
Thank you for taking the time to review. I'm glad you enjoyed the story -- I certainly had a great time writing it!
mary-v
Sunday 26th February 2006 19:43
The Thaw
I absolutely adored this. The dry humor you had going on was brilliant, especiall this bit: "By the time they reached the Burrow, the automaton with the frozen heart was ready to walk and talk, almost like a real boy." Great job. Though I really wish we'd have seen them facing the Weasleys. Especially Fred and George.

Excellent
~Maria~
Wednesday 1st March 2006 09:22The Thaw (Author Response)
Thank you for your kind words. It is possible that I might bring this story forzard at some point, although canonically speaking it has been overtaken by events. In any case, though, I am confident that Ginny as I have imagined her is more than a match for her brothers.
IHateSnakes
Monday 3rd October 2005 06:04
The Thaw
Wow!  What a great way to start the week.  Beautiful imagery.  Thanks for writing it.  S.
Tuesday 11th October 2005 20:24The Thaw (Author Response)
And thank you for reviewing.  Glad you liked the images - in many ways this story was built around them, and what little plot it has came later.
jeanne
Sunday 28th August 2005 07:11
The Thaw
I have no doubt reviewed this before,but after reading it again,I must agree with M&L,s,in as much as it is a really great work of art. I could picture and live every word and action.Even the last scene with Ginny placing his hand on her breast was not really a sexual act ,as much as a show of faith and trust in Harry to accept her into his life as a full partner and eventually lover. Her deep love for him dragged him up out of the deepest depths of despair,and self-loathing,and you did it all awesomely.My Thanks to you.
Friday 2nd September 2005 20:03The Thaw (Author Response)
You're welcome.  I enjoyed writing this story, and it is always good to hear that others enjoy reading it.  You are quite right that the final scene, and the whole story really, is about mutual faith. (Not that there's anything wrong with a good snog, mind you.)
Spyder
Saturday 9th July 2005 23:43
The Thaw
Controversy??? I love this story.  I think Ginny is very cannon in it... and better, she's real (well as real as any fictional character anyway).  This has to be one of my favourite Ginny/ Harry stories (if not my favourite).  Sequel please.
Saturday 16th July 2005 00:51The Thaw (Author Response)
Thanks for your review (and sorry for the delay in replying).  I'm glad you find my Ginne "real".  She became much more so to me as I wrote this.  Swquel ... I keep saying that there will be one, but so far it hasn't happened.   Eventually, however, I think there will be. 
MollyW
Tuesday 1st March 2005 11:38
The Thaw
I loved your story! This is pretty much how I've imagined Harry's "thaw" occurring. I don't think it's out of the realms of possibility for canon either, although the relationship would not go so far in canon. I think your Ginny is absolutely in character according to canon. She was the one who yelled at Harry at Grimauld Place, has put up with 6 older brothers, is the only other person his age to face Voldemort and survive, the one he talks to int he library, and the person for whom "anything is possible if you've got enough nerve." I really hope that Voldemort is taking out by Harry and Ginny joining forces. They share a special bond that I believe will be helpful int he end. If not in HBP, then maybe in Book 7. Great Job! Thank you!
Macsr71
Tuesday 8th February 2005 15:54
The Thaw

I have read many - many stories that are much longer than this but fail to even come close to the depth and feeling packed in here. This very well could be one of the ways she saves him and, by extention, the rest of the wizarding world.

Nicely done.

Wednesday 9th February 2005 06:52The Thaw (Author Response)

Glad you liked it. 

"Ginny Weasley Saves the World"  -- kind of a catchy title now that you mention it ...

jabarber69
Tuesday 25th January 2005 10:15
The Thaw

I just read your story, I must say to hell with others and what they might say about it not being in canon, this was outstanding. And who says it not in canon. JK Rowlin who is an outstanding author, created the characters but they are not written in stone! Most of the outstanding stories I have read would be considered AU. Hell for that matter, every story not written by Mrs. Rowlin would have to be considered AU since she didn't write them.

I like your version of Harry and especially Ginny. You have a unique understanding of teenagers and the angst generated with Sirius death and what would be needed by the Harry character to start to heal. You also have the necessary understanding of Ron's and Hermione characters as well.

I just wish this wasn't complete, I would love to see this story continued and the penseive and what they do with the info...

 

Tuesday 1st February 2005 06:35The Thaw (Author Response)

Thanks for the kind words.  I too would like to see the story continued, and I trust that it eventually will be but, for the time being, I am back to working on other projects.  As for questions of canon, I am not as fanatic on the subject as some, but it is the game we play after all, so it's worth trying to play it well. 

Wonko
Friday 7th January 2005 00:59
The Thaw
that was absolutely wonderful

" She looked up at him, all the while keeping firm hold of a wrist connected to a hand that was working out all on its own that the word 'cup' could also be used as a verb. A bright grin lit up her face." made me laugh =) as did many other things, now that I think of it. I'm terrible at knowing what to say about a story, but I really hope you'll be sharing more with us soon.

I completely forgot that I was supposed to be looking for an AtE reference and missed it completely, I'll have another read soon =)

And what's this about a refined audience? I did a Google search but weak at the knees is a fairly common phrase.
Friday 7th January 2005 11:02The Thaw (Author Response)

Now, see, I think you're really good at finding things to say about a story.  You zeroed in on my personal favorite sentence (in fact, it may not be altogether impossible that the whole rest of a story was just a pretext to get that bit in ...). 

Thanks!

SueP
Thursday 6th January 2005 18:13
The Thaw
I liked this - I really really liked this. Ginny is great - tough, supportive, and honest. Just the way I picture her too. I have great hopes that our vision of Ginny becomes etched in book 7. Well done.
Kokopelli
Thursday 6th January 2005 14:32
The Thaw
Setting aside notions of character change in an afternoon, this is a brilliant story - very compact and economical. 

Thanks  - I hope that more is coming.

JEC
Friday 7th January 2005 11:08The Thaw (Author Response)

Coming from you, this is high praise.  Thank you.

Compact and economical -- yes, this is what I was striving for (if for no other reason that I simply don't think I have 200k words in me at this point).  Crises, meanwhile, do not suddenly build (or change) character, but they do sometimes reveal it rather abruptly.  The way I imagine it, the changes consumated that afternoon had been building for a very long time indeed.

critmo
Thursday 6th January 2005 07:23
The Thaw
One word: FABULOUS!
I just would have loved to see them facing the others...
Sanguisiphiliac
Wednesday 5th January 2005 21:25
The Thaw
*laughter* beautiful! I have no idea what you were talking about in your A/N - I thought Ginny was very much in character. Amazing job!
Thursday 6th January 2005 12:50The Thaw (Author Response)
Thanks ever so much -- and I am particularly flattered that my first story should be the object of your first review.  Newbies should stick together !
DADAGinny
Wednesday 5th January 2005 12:10
The Thaw
"the recent elopement of their sister in the company of one Dean Thomas".  Grinning at that one.

Wow, Harry really is numb.  I feel so sorry for him.

Love the part where Ginny is playing "follow the leader" on broomsticks with him.

I like how you have him tell the truth to Ginny -- in OotP she seemed to be the only one he really confided in (thinking library).

"you weren't the only one getting extra tutoring from Ravenclaw last year."  I am thinking I shouldn't be reading this at work (internal mirth, trying not to laugh)

"This is how it is, Harry. This is the only truth that matters. All of me is for you just like all of you is for me, and no one but us decides how, and where, and when"  Sigh.

What a wonderful story.  Thank you for sharing.


Wednesday 5th January 2005 16:23The Thaw (Author Response)

Always happy to make the work day a little brighter ... Thanks for the kind words.

J

rdprice29
Tuesday 4th January 2005 12:18
The Thaw

I like this!  Ginny does seem a little old here than 15, but she's been through a lot the last 5 years, so I can believe it!

Great job!

clareindil
Tuesday 4th January 2005 00:50
The Thaw

Oh I wish that was how it will be in canon. Such a lovely mix of grief and laughter. I particularly liked the knee.Now I may be refined but I'd love to know more about Weak at the Knees. Where is it, please? I agree with those who would like to find out what happens when they return to the family. I found myself happily continuing the story in my head but it wasn't you, was it? Please go on.

clare

Tuesday 4th January 2005 01:57The Thaw (Author Response)

Thanks for your kind words.  I did work hard to keep this scene from being just totally sappy.

A number of reviewers have paid me the compliment of asking what happens next (and I hope you won't mind my using this response to address that question more generally).  The good news is that I do indeed plan to follow up on this scene.  The bad news is that I don't see myself describing Harry's birthday dinner in any detail.  Partly this is for technical reasons -- the way I write lends itself much more to dialogues than to conversational free-for-alls such as I imagine a Weasley dinner to be.  In any case, what interests me more, at least at this point, is how Hermione is going to react to this sudden shift in the situation, so I'm thinking that  what you all have to look forward to next are some Harry-Hermione and Ginny-Hermione scenes.  (In the meantime, anyone who wants pick up the thread and go with it is welcome to.  That's the fun of fan fction.)

A word, finally, with respect to the stories cited in the A/N.  The classics are classics for a reason and are easily found.  The other one is obscure for a reason, and a quick search today leads me to think that either its author or the Internet-Purity-League has removed it from general circulation.  In retrospect I probably shouldn't have mentioned it at all, but that willow tree was bothering my conscience ...

Ph03n1x
Monday 3rd January 2005 22:56
The Thaw

...I don't know what to say except... wow... just wow...

That was amazing!  I really like it!  I can't wait to see what else you end up writing!

TigerLily8186
Monday 3rd January 2005 20:52
The Thaw

Oh this was great fun to read. There were so many little lines that I loved when reading.

"What Harry was actually doing, although he didn't realize it at the time, was putting to good use the skills that he would not admit to having acquired as a result of his lessons from Professor Snape in the art of Occlumency. Higher and stronger he built his defenses, more intent on keeping out his friends than he had ever been on eluding his enemy." I found this particularly poignant. Like many other passages in this, the sentiments and feelings are beautifully written.

"Slowly the frozen heart began to thaw.
And then, after a moment in which it became abundantly clear that the Boy who Lived had no clue what to do next …

"Harry?"

"Yes …"

"Brace yourself."" I found this quite an enduring Ginny aspect. Like most of the Weasleys, she would not be one to beat around the bush.

"Listen like you've never listened to anything before in your life, because if there's one thing I know more about than you do, it's Tom Riddle. I am the world's leading bloody authority on Tom Riddle. I've been Tom Riddle!" This is quite a good point. I guess I hadn't realized before that Ginny is going to be the one to tell Harry how he is not like Tom. This act will probably be very important, though it will most likely happen a little later on, it fit quite nicely into your story.

"What I'm about to say … please believe me when I tell you that it has absolutely nothing to do with fact that my hand is … where it is right now, OK?" I loved how you had serious bits intermingled with some great teenage realities (I think that is the point I am trying to say).

I know you stated at the beginning at how this was just an exercise of sorts, but it is quite a well written and characterly developed exercise. I look forward to reading more of your works. (And you have only made me slightly curious as to the Weak at the Knees story which you briefly mentioned.)

~Megs... wow I guess my review is quite long..oops

mary-v
Monday 3rd January 2005 15:26
The Thaw

 This was GREAT! I really enjoyed reading this! I loved every little part of this story, and  hope you write more really soon!

Happy New Year!

~Maria~

mary-v
Monday 3rd January 2005 15:26
The Thaw

 This was GREAT! I really enjoyed reading this! I loved every little part of this story, and  hope you write more really soon!

Happy New Year!

~Maria~

mary-v
Monday 3rd January 2005 15:26
The Thaw

 This was GREAT! I really enjoyed reading this! I loved every little part of this story, and  hope you write more really soon!

Happy New Year!

~Maria~

HPNana
Monday 3rd January 2005 13:16
The Thaw

WOW ! Your story blew me away.

 OUTSTANDING!

Mitch Bennett
Monday 3rd January 2005 11:49
The Thaw
Good!  Very good! Though I don't exactly agree with your interpertation of Ginny's evolution, it was nicely written and quite entertaining actualy.  Though this might seem a bit... pompus please allow me to give you one tiny bit of advice for the future.  Never apologise for your characterazations.  Its your story, if they don't like the way you portray them, they can either cope or find something else to read.
Neely61
Monday 3rd January 2005 10:04
The Thaw

 and  sittin' under a tree, K. I. SS. I. N. G!  Aargh! Fluff attack!  Beware the bouncing hairballs!   Ok, now that I've taken my insulen I can continue.  I am with several of the other viewers in that I would at least like to see one more followup to this with the party and the family's reactions to Harry and Gin's newly formed relationship as well as a conversation with Dumbledore about what they discussed.  Whatever you write I will be adding you to my update list so don't keep us waiting, get back to writing.

 

z26
Monday 3rd January 2005 02:04
The Thaw
This story is absolutely amazing.  You got the teenage hormones, war angst, and cute fluffiness all in one little story.

Thanks for writing!
Jelsemium
Monday 3rd January 2005 01:47
The Thaw

I really liked this story! I feel that your characters are interesting. I particularly like your depictions of Harry in shock and trying very hard to not feel anything.

(I loved the car scene, when Fred threw in that information about Ginny eloping to see if Harry was listening. Great touch.)

I like how Ginny thawed Harry out. I think you are absolutely right on this front. Talking to Harry isn’t going to help him at this point. He just needs the comfort of human touch.

Your writing style is quite elegant. You do a good job in setting the feel of a scene and your dialog is spot on, I think.

I do have one complaint... your author's note. I really don't care for long author's notes at the beginning of the story. An acknowledgement of your influences shouldn't take more than a sentence or two.

You should not apologize or defend your characterization (and certainly not before anybody criticizes it). We know you're not J. K. Rowling. (If you are, though, can I have your autograph?)  Long author notes tend to put readers off.

I got this rule of writing from Marion Zimmer Bradley:  "If you think there's something wrong with the story, then fix it."

To which I add: If you think the story is good enough to post (and yours goes considerably beyond "good"), just post it. Don't anticipate criticism.

Monday 3rd January 2005 10:10The Thaw (Author Response)
Thanks ever so much.  And you are right about the A/N, of course.
XiaoXiao
Monday 3rd January 2005 01:00
The Thaw

Very cute.  I didn't mind Ginny's bossiness, because Harry really does need someone to take over once in a while.  Besides, she's encouragingly bossy. 

The way that Ginny's victimization can be turned around is a great idea, and I hope that some version of that happens in canon. 

Loved this bit: I'm in charge, you hang on for the ride, and everyone else look out below.

Arnel
Monday 3rd January 2005 00:22
The Thaw
I love your Ginny; she's so kind and caring and spunky and oh, sooooo patient!  I love how she just let Harry "thaw" under that tree and learn to accept what his life has dealt him.  I love how she opened up and poured something of herself into Harry; how she let him know that she wasn't the only one hurt by Voldemort and that what she knew could be as painful as it was useful and that she needed him.  I also love that she wouldn't take "no" for an answer at any time during their tryst under the tree.  The intimacey of the end seems to be an affirmation of Ginny's love for and faith in Harry, something he needs terribly.  By now, I suspect that you know how much I enjoyed your story.  I hope you post again soon.
emmamoonpotter
Sunday 2nd January 2005 22:58
The Thaw
I really, really, really liked this story.  I always believed it would be something like this between Harry and Ginny.  She is not pushy like Hermione and not as clueless as Ron.  She knows!  The interaction between Harry and Ginny is flawless, and I can see them sitting together in comfortable silence.  Bravo!  
Melindaleo
Sunday 2nd January 2005 20:43
The Thaw
This was wonderful.  A story I know I'll read again and again.  I had no problem with your Ginny, I quite enjoyed her.  You're right, JKR isn't going to give us this...exactly...so we have to fill in the blanks.  My blanks are thrilled at the moment.  Nice job.
Aberforth's Avatar
Sunday 2nd January 2005 20:19
The Thaw

This was great fun to read.  I can't see JKR starting off HBP this way, but I enjoyed your story quite a lot.  I don't find your Ginny OOC, although perhaps acting a bit older than her age.  I did like her fierceness, and found her insistence on honesty refreshing.  I loved the line, "If you even think of apologizing at this point, I will hurt you. A lot."  I think the whole story well thought-out, and very well put together.  The only false note, to me, was Harry's reference to seeing Dumbledore right away with Ginny's information.  I think Harry has too high a regard for his privacy to rush into compromising some one else's. 

I don't know how much more of this idea is kicking around in your mind, but it would be wonderful to see some of these themes fleshed out a bit more.  Thanks so much for sharing this.  You've given us a lot to think about; and I'll definitely be looking for more of your work to read.

Sunday 2nd January 2005 20:43The Thaw (Author Response)
Thanks, it was great fun to write.  To be honest, I didn't really think of going to Dumbledore as a privacy issue.  I seem to have assumed (without fully working it out in my own mind) that Ginny's telling Harry means that she is now ready to act on this information, which necessarily means getting others involved.  You are quite right, though.  The least Harry could have done would have been to ask her how she felt about this ... But then, that's our Harry -- not exactly the world's most tactful fellow.
weasleysrcool
Sunday 2nd January 2005 18:44
The Thaw
I liked this a lot.  I have to admit that Ginny did shock me a little, but it was a good shock, and I can understand it.  I enjoyed the whole fic.  Thanks for sharing it with us here. 
Robert Owen
Sunday 2nd January 2005 18:22
The Thaw

Aside from the part about going to Dumbledore (which I can't quite see Harry doing at this point) I see nothing here that wouldn't be out of line with the opening of HBP.  Great story and I'd love to see it continue, at least through the b-day party and Ron's reaction to them as a couple (combined maybe with a bit of R/Hr finally getting a clue)  Bravo all around.

Robert

 

Sunday 2nd January 2005 19:23The Thaw (Author Response)

I agree that the reconciliation with Dumbledore is a bit sudden (although I try to foreshadow it just a bit by having Harry express regret for his behaviour in the Spring).  The way I see it, the twin shocks of the afternoon  (and, in this case, mostly Ginny's new information) have gone a long way toward helping Harry get over his resentment on that front -- although I don't think he will ever go back to idealizing his Headmaster as once he did.  Practically speaking, in any case, where else is Harry going to go for this sort of high-level technical help?

 

arios
Sunday 2nd January 2005 16:00
The Thaw
 Have you considered expanding this into a multi chapter story? I loved it!
Sunday 2nd January 2005 19:37The Thaw (Author Response)
I can't promise a full-blown multi-chapter story (I write Very slowly and, quite frankly, don't have a plot in mind) but I feel reasonably confident that there will be more vignettes of this kind.
MagnoliaMama
Sunday 2nd January 2005 15:31
The Thaw
I thought this was just fabulous. Your characterization of Ginny, though perhaps a bit advanced for her years, is still recognizable. I love her sense of humor and mischief that's dangerous, yet not quite to the extent that the twins are dangerous. More importantly, I thought your characterization of Harry was perfect. I especially liked that "talking it out" didn't tear down his barriers, but rather simple physical closeness with a warm body -- something he's been deprived of all his life. His speech and mannerisms in this fic make him sound like the unsure, repressed 16-year-old boy (I think) he really is. Truly, a marvelous story!
Sunday 2nd January 2005 19:34The Thaw (Author Response)

Thak you for the kind words.  Two points you bring up:

Advanced for her age -- yes, actually they all are both in Cannon and in most fic.  It's a general feature of school stories.  In this case we can rationalize it by remembering that they've all been through some pretty harrowing experiences by this point.

Physical closeness -- I'm glad you liked that because, for me, it's absolutely central to who Harry is.  Never mind romance for the moment, Harry has gone through life absolutely starved even for the sort of ordinary casual touching that is part of any healthy family, and that's one thing for which school has not provided a substitute.  The Weasleys, on the other hand, are presented as a very hugging sort of family, so this is (yet another) area in which Ginny is way ahead of him. 

 

thehopefulGinnyPotter
Sunday 2nd January 2005 15:14
The Thaw
Oh tha twas absolutely lovely!
martita
Sunday 2nd January 2005 14:44
The Thaw

I can definetly see canon!Ginny do at least some of this, if not quite so... far.

I liked this fic very much, and I like your writing style.  Keep up the good work!

Spark Soliton
Sunday 2nd January 2005 13:14
The Thaw

              

YES!!! Brilliant!!! One of the best portrayals of Ginny I've read so far; strong, determined, daring and yet caring. I really, really liked this fic, you've done a super job in telling this story - enough detail to paint a good picture to help the 'mind's eye' yet not too detailed to bog down the story. Good, nicely flowing dialogue that feels natural and actually, rather canon-like behaviour from the main characters, at least in my opinion. I definately think that this type of Ginny is foreshadowed in OotP - whilst all the others walk tenderly around Harry she is the only one to break his funks and who is not afraid to tell him off when needed. She does not fear him, not in the slightest. I'm very impressed with 'your' Ginny - many other writers tend to depict her as weak and giggly, frightened to show her undying love for Harry. This feels much more real and proper. Thank for writing and sharing this - may I hope for a continuation?

Sunday 2nd January 2005 19:41The Thaw (Author Response)
Thanks!  No weak, giggly Ginny's from me -- that much, at least, I can promise.
Majick
Sunday 2nd January 2005 13:04
The Thaw

Well, no, I'm pretty sure that that isn't something that'll be showing up in the books. It is something, however, that seems perfectly plausible. A little bit of H/G proto-smut would certainly go a long way to sorting out Harry's head, I feel, and teaching him that life goes on even without all the loved ones that he's lost.

Ginny certainly shows a great deal of maturity here, more then many girls her age would have been capable of. The possession of her mind by Tom Riddle was doubtless a sobering and maturing experience for her, and she knows in exquisite detail what it is to be a sixteen year old boy, and one with definite problems to boot. Who better to shock Harry out of his funk?

The whole story has a verve and humour about it not often seen. A step shy of direct narrative, your descriptions of Harry in particular wink at the reader with a real impudence that makes your tale a real pleasure to read.

BabyRuth
Sunday 2nd January 2005 12:40
The Thaw
Very satisfying!  I like your Ginny putting Harry back on the right track.  Wouldn't mind seeing other stories or a longer chaptered one along this vein, like what happens with the pensieve.