Authors: - A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P R S T V W X Y Z

Reviews For The Knights of Walpurgis by Majick

sherriola
Tuesday 16th June 2015 06:15
The Knights of Walpurgis
i'm glad to have found this story and I'm looking forward to seeing what happens. Loved Harry taking things into his own hands, dumbledore, blood protection, all of it be damned. grin. But what's with Ginny trying to force him to talk aobut sirius? Everyone grieves differently. My dad died 18 years ago, and I still do not speak of it or much of him, and I'd clobber anyone who tried to force me. lol.
Curt
Saturday 22nd January 2005 19:29
The Knights of Walpurgis
Review for Chapter 2.

Amazing, simply put, and I am very much a fan now. I really like your style of writing, the small details, the flow, dialogue - everything is done well in my opinion.

I really like the small details implemented in your story, i.e., Phineas' portrait, the comment about Fred's motorbike in the bedroom etc.

The way Harry reacted to being back in Grimmauld's Place was simply fantastic. This is the first story I've read where Harry actually considers the place his home. Most authors assumed the because Sirius hated it, Harry would too. But I love your touch on how since Sirius lived there, Harry felt strongly about the house.

The dialogue between Harry and Ginny was absolutely great, very well written. It sounded real in my opinon, and my real I mean that I could see it happening in a future Harry Potter book.

I was also kind of surprised at how nasty Mrs. Figg acted...Anyway, amazing chapter, once again I am definetly a fan now, I think I need a 'majick' t-shirt. Ha. Keep writing.
Sunday 23rd January 2005 15:26The Knights of Walpurgis (Author Response)

I like putting details like Fred's bike into my stories, as I think a bit of background to a story helps keep it going. Phines in particular is a character I adore, and I keep trying to find ways to add scenes in Dumbledore's office to the story so that I can keep him coing back in. Maybe I'll move the portrait to the Gryffindor common room...

Mrs. Figg was deeply disappointed in Harry. His actions on learning of Remus' injury showed no apparent change from the way he reacted to Sirius' supposed capture weeks before.

As for Grimmmauld Place, well, anywhere would be better than Privet Drive, right?

Thanks for reviewing. If you want to stay up to date with my stories, head over to http://groups.yahoo.com/group/majickalwriting/

Genevieve
Friday 21st January 2005 17:36
The Knights of Walpurgis
Yay with the darkness!  Not that I should be cheering it, but I am.  Harry's snapping, yet at the same time, he's also taking things rather in stride and plunging on ahead.  He has his moments but he's got MORE than those moments.  :)
Sunday 23rd January 2005 15:23The Knights of Walpurgis (Author Response)
Harry's beginning to make his way back to normality, and will make significant strides in the next chapter. There'll be plenty of moments on both sides to come, though.
SillyGillie
Tuesday 18th January 2005 16:33
The Knights of Walpurgis

Awesome chapter!

You are the first person that has made elections for a new Minister of Magic, even though JK Rowling said that there was going to be. I keep trying to convince people to at least kill off Fudge, but it doesn't seem to be working. However, I'm glad that you are making elections!!! 

Lovely chapter!

Wednesday 19th January 2005 16:55The Knights of Walpurgis (Author Response)

Not just elections, but a whole lot of intrigue in the Ministry in this story. Although I'm confined to Harry's POV, the Prophet will be sure to report all the important facts

As for Fudge, well, I think he's a bit useless, but probably not worth killing. There'll be a few deaths along the way, alas...

Maximaleeni
Monday 17th January 2005 12:58
The Knights of Walpurgis

I'm determined to review the right chapter this time...

Go the Harry/Ginny moment!

I loved this bit too :

" "My great-great-grandson would be proud of you, I imagine," a rather bored voice announced from the wall. "The lure of emotional distress is often just too much for women to resist."

Without any change in his expression, Harry rose and crossed to the portrait of Phineas Nigellus, former headmaster of Hogwarts and Sirius' great-great-grandfather. He turned it over, ignoring the offended sound from the portrait's subject and left it facing the wall. "

So funny!

Great new chapter! Can't wait for the next one.

Wednesday 19th January 2005 16:53The Knights of Walpurgis (Author Response)

I love Phineas' character. I must try and get him into the story more often, although as he's so limited in location, there isn't too much scope for it.

Harry/Ginny moments are fun, especially when one or both parties is oblivious to them

Neely61
Sunday 16th January 2005 22:34
The Knights of Walpurgis
I always love stories when Mrs. Blacks pic gets taken out.  I've seen a few and this is the first one where someone (namely Harry) just ripped her to pieces.  Loved it!   Can't wait to see what else you have planned so stop reading this and get back at it!
Wednesday 19th January 2005 16:52The Knights of Walpurgis (Author Response)

I cut a whole scene where Harry just went nuts and hexed the painting to pieces, mainly because I'm sure someone in the Order would have tried. I was fairly sure that the no-one would have thought to protect the canvas from outright physical attacks, though, because what pureblood would stoop to dirtying their hands?

Rest assured that I've got a lot planned for the story, including the obligatory new DADA teacher, and the return of the old one...

Melindaleo
Sunday 16th January 2005 21:32
The Knights of Walpurgis
I had trouble with the last review, so I'm not sure if it went through.  But I really liked this chapter.  I liked Harry's reaction when Mrs. Weasley woke him up, and I like how Ginny is the one he's letting in. I can't wait for more.
Wednesday 19th January 2005 16:50The Knights of Walpurgis (Author Response)

More soon  Glad to have you on board again. A few people have criticised Harry's moods in these chapters, but he's not in the best state of mind. In the next few chapters things will start to pick up for him. I just hope that it isn't all too soon.

I think Ginny's a natural new friend for Harry. It's been said before, but she's been shown to be persistent, headstrong, kind and trustworthy, all traits that Harry's friends need. She also doesn't need to worry about Harry deciding to stop talking to her, as they've only exchanged about three words in canon so far.

Sherbert
Sunday 16th January 2005 16:38
The Knights of Walpurgis

Yay - another chapter! You've obviously spent a lot of time linking this in with incidents in Order of the Phoenix. I loved the description of the entrance hall at the hospital. Harry seems quite unstable still although I found the destruction of the painting curious - he's controlled enough to ask for permission to destroy it but then seems to lose control in actually doing so. Maybe it is a way of him venting his temper/emotions in a reasonably harmless manner? I like the way Ginny and Harry are starting to speak. Are they going to get together in this book? Hope the next chapter is soon.

Sunday 16th January 2005 17:33The Knights of Walpurgis (Author Response)

Harry's emotions are completely off the wall at this moment, but he'll find a way to calm himself in moments of stress, and it may even help him with his Occlumency.

A lot happened in OotP that had to be addressed in this story, not least how messed up Harry was going to be by all that he'd seen and done. He won't necessarily get better overnight, but the pieces will start to fall into place as the year goes on.

Other things you might want to watch for as the year goes on: The changes in Harry's relationship with Dumbledore, the effects Ron's encounter with the brain in the Ministry, the fallout from Snape's Worst Memory, Luna's interest in a certain Gryffindor and how Draco Malfoy is coping with his life as the son of a known Death Eater...

Harry and Ginny? In this book? Right at the moment, I'm leaning towards, 'Well, maybe' and considering that at the start of the story I was at 'Absolutely not' then I suppose that could be progress...