gymnastgal19
Saturday 13th October 2007 15:42 | Choices |
awwww!!! this is so sweet! This is the first fanfic that ive read about sir nic! I love how you used the viel to get him to the other side!!!
Thank you for writting this! |
Concealed
Thursday 27th October 2005 20:23 | Choices |
| Wow. So very amazing. But so sad. Although it had a happy ending, it
was sad that the only way to find closure was to "truly" die. Oh, well,
at least he's happy. ^^
|
ridgeback77
Thursday 27th October 2005 15:26 | Choices |
| That was such a lovely story. It does leave me with one question though, who will now watch over Gryffindor?
|
Emily
Thursday 27th October 2005 07:09 | Choices |
Such a lovely tale you have written here ^^
I adore the entire prospect, so sad, yet heartwarming. |
| Thursday 27th October 2005 11:24 | Choices (Author Response) |
| Thank you! I appreciate the review. |
BasketKiwi
Wednesday 26th October 2005 19:42 | Choices |
| Wow! What an interesting perspective! I loved it, even if it was sad. I liked the ending most of all! (I've got a "thing" for happy endings!) Anyway, good job with the story and congrats on getting "Story of the Week" thing! ^^ |
| Thursday 27th October 2005 11:24 | Choices (Author Response) |
Thank you so much! I too have a thing for 'happy endings'!
|
Ladybug
Wednesday 26th October 2005 01:39 | Choices |
| That was an ingenious idea and very beautifully expressed, from Dumbledore's advice to Nick's letters, and especially the glimpse of his life before death. What I liked most was the very end when he took on bodily form once more and the full use of his senses. A well-deserved Story of the Week. Well done. |
| Thursday 27th October 2005 11:25 | Choices (Author Response) |
Thank you so, so much. I'm so pleased you enjoyed it. :) |
Gioia
Monday 24th October 2005 10:25 | Choices |
| Oh, that was really sweet! What a great idea, that the veil could
be a way for Sir Nick to end his ghostly existence and finally gain
some peace! I love Dumbledore's speach about his certainty of an
afterlife and answers about this one. What I particularly enjoyed
was how these alternate perspectives gave Sirius's death some meaning
and peace. Well done!
|
| Tuesday 25th October 2005 08:20 | Choices (Author Response) |
| Thank you! I'm so pleased you enjoyed this; it's always been one of my favorites that I've written. |
Stephanie
Monday 24th October 2005 05:34 | Choices |
| What a wonderful, heart-warming story. I really enjoyed it, thanks for sharing :). |
| Tuesday 25th October 2005 08:21 | Choices (Author Response) |
| Thank you so, so much! I really appreciate the review. |
amamama
Tuesday 16th August 2005 05:58 | Choices |
Awww, wonderful! So sad the Gryffindor's won't have their house
ghost anymore, but there might be another one coming along? For
Sir Nicholas to find peace and love like this.. what can I say?
Marvellous ide, brilliantly written, full of care and compassion.
Finally he was ready for his next great adventure.
Thanks!
|
| Wednesday 17th August 2005 13:14 | Choices (Author Response) |
| Thank you so much for the review. I'm so glad you liked it. :) |
Cambryn
Monday 21st March 2005 05:06 | Choices |
| That was a perfectly lovely story. It made my eyes tear at the end. It's wonderful seeing someone write a story from a unique persepctive, or about a character who is rarely written about. Lovely job. |
