Authors: - A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P R S T V W X Y Z

Reviews For Lingering Doubt by Pirate Ginny

gymnastgal19
Saturday 29th March 2008 10:16
Lingering Doubt
wow... you never really think that ginny would be worried that Voldemort will use her to get info about the order.... good thing that never happened...
haha i love the ending
EmeraldPrincess
Sunday 9th April 2006 15:20
Lingering Doubt
i think u meant 3 years..
SillyGillie
Sunday 13th November 2005 10:43
Lingering Doubt

Really nice outtake. I loved it. Aww Ginny and Bill are so sweet together. I wish JK would go more into their relationship! I loved this quote!

"Ginny defended the socks as though they were Professor Dumbledore himself."

Tuesday 3rd January 2006 15:34Lingering Doubt (Author Response)
:)  I wanted to show some way that Ginny felt as defensive of Dumbledore as she does of Harry and Sirius...and as Harry does of Dumbledore, for that matter.

Maybe we'll get to see more of the Ginny/Bill relationship in the next book, with the wedding.  :is hopeful:
brad
Wednesday 21st September 2005 18:32
Lingering Doubt
Nice little story!  Always good to get a reminder of what Ginny went through with Tom in her first year; like Bill I sometimes forget.  And I thought it was clever of you to have Dumbledore refer back to Harry's report of Voldemort's discourse from his resurrection.  Good story, thanks!
Sunday 2nd October 2005 18:02Lingering Doubt (Author Response)
This was written to settle my mind, I think.  Voldemort's discourse still intrigues me.  I wonder, wonder about it still.
Lady Ginny Potter
Saturday 4th June 2005 17:42
Lingering Doubt
Lovely!  And you are right about Voldemort not saying anything about Harry's second year, of course he could have left that out for a reason....hmmm, something for me to ponder.  Make more chapters!
Saturday 4th June 2005 19:06Lingering Doubt (Author Response)
Yes.  Voldemort could have left it for a reason.  I suppose we'll see if anything comes of it.  Maybe nothing.  I couldn't help but notice how very nervous Ginny got at the Ministry, after the Death Eaters showed up--at least, I'm assuming it was nervousness.  She was quiet, just as she was quiet when Mr. Weasley was in St. Mungos.

No more chapters in this one--but more fics.  Stay tuned. 
Wolf's Scream
Thursday 2nd June 2005 14:15
Lingering Doubt
What can I say?  I enjoyed it; well-written.  :-)
Thursday 2nd June 2005 19:08Lingering Doubt (Author Response)
Thanks! 
Penny Lane
Thursday 2nd June 2005 09:00
Lingering Doubt

It's official:  You write the best Ginny in fanfiction.  Really, you have such a good grasp of her character, it's just.... wow. 

Your Dumbledore is pretty great, too.  I know everyone's already said it before me, but I loved that she decided to knit him socks -- such a Ginny thing to do. 

The last line was perfect.

*fangirls you to death* 

Thursday 2nd June 2005 14:15Lingering Doubt (Author Response)

 Thanks, PL.  You've made my day.  I think I might actually die from head explosion via your fangirling.

Blame Happydog for the last line.  I had it ending with Ginny's line about the dragonfang, and he made me write just a bit more.  beta=right as usual. 

 

Antonia East
Wednesday 1st June 2005 17:38
Lingering Doubt
Oh that's lovely.  You do Ginny so well!  I like the way that her possession is still a great part of her - although she's good at hiding it - but that she's working on resolving it rather than shutting it out. The mention of her wearing Bill's jumper the summer afterwards was a nice touch.  Ginny's interaction with Dumbledore and Bill was brilliant.  I loved the aside of Tonks talking about (and acting out) Fudge, as well as the mention of Mrs Black's knickers!

A quick pick up - it's Lucius, rather than Lucious. I also have little diamonds with question marks in instead of commas -  I don't know whether that's my computer or funny formatting.
Wednesday 1st June 2005 18:35Lingering Doubt (Author Response)
Gah!  "Lucious."  *&^% auto-correct!  I thought we fixed that, but I guess not.  Oh, well.  So I look silly.  I could look worse things.  (The formatting is all around.  We've had conversion Issues...)

And, on a more sublime note...

Among a myriad other reasons, I really wanted to write something that explained what I noticed about Ginny at the Ministry.  After the Death Eaters show up, she withdraws almost to silence again.  Of course, there's the "Lucky you" line as well, but I wanted something a bit more.  (Hee.  And why else do we write fanfiction anyway?)

I'm so glad that the little details worked for you.  The knickers might be my favorite...I don't know why, but knickers (to me) are a bit like bananas, a pie in the face, and whoopie cushions: always good for a laugh.  
EvieMarie
Wednesday 1st June 2005 15:34
Lingering Doubt
That was good. I really like the interaction with Bill and Ginny; you established their relationship well. And I really like the idea or Ginny knitting Dumbledore socks! :P
Wednesday 1st June 2005 18:39Lingering Doubt (Author Response)
Thanks!  It was fun to write a scene with Bill and Ginny. And Dumbledore...I thought he really needed some warm socks.  
makotochi
Wednesday 1st June 2005 12:38
Lingering Doubt

That was pretty good

Wednesday 1st June 2005 13:37Lingering Doubt (Author Response)
Thanks. 
Katieay
Wednesday 1st June 2005 12:20
Lingering Doubt

Oh so well done! I love your characterisation of... well, everyone! Being a rabid Snape-hater, this bit made me grin widely.

Ginny grinned when she saw Snape scowling at Mundungus; Mundungus stood between Snape and the cloak rack.

“Step aside, Fletcher,” he said.

Ginny was heart-wrenchingly sweet. I think we learned in OotP, with two short words, that Ginny is far from overcoming her experience in the Chamber, and so Bill's comment about them forgetting was especially poignant. And it's so like Ginny to knit Dumbledore his socks! The barking thought made me chuckle. I thought that Ginny could have felt a bit more when Mrs. Weasley yelled her full name in front of all those people -- something she's yet to do in Canon. You had Dumbledore's randomness spot on, I just love this little piece! Well done

Wednesday 1st June 2005 13:36Lingering Doubt (Author Response)

Heehee.  I love to goad Snape.  I don't hate him...I feel toward him what Gred and Forge feel for Filch, I think. 

So glad that you liked the characterizations.  You're absolutely right about Ginny and her name being called.  Meh.  I had something in there, but it didn't fit.  (Thinking about it now, I'd probably just alter what Molly shouts.  When text is in caps, I have a hard time editing it.  )

I love Dumbledore.  I thought he deserved some handmade socks. 

MagnoliaMama
Wednesday 1st June 2005 04:55
Lingering Doubt
Oh, very nice. I've often wondered why this particular issue didn't come up in OotP myself. You captured Dumbledore's voice very well, and I especially liked the scene with Bill at the end. The implications of the hex on Mrs. Black's knickers though... poor Mr. Black. 
Wednesday 1st June 2005 13:25Lingering Doubt (Author Response)

Thank you. 

Heehee.  Why do I get the feeling that Mr. Black wouldn't even need the hex as a deterent.   

I was wondering the same.  Who knows?  Maybe it'll come up later...

critmo
Wednesday 1st June 2005 02:00
Lingering Doubt
Well done, and not at all unlikely.
Wednesday 1st June 2005 13:16Lingering Doubt (Author Response)
Thanks, Critmo.    I suppose we'll see...
brad
Tuesday 31st May 2005 21:51
Lingering Doubt
Very nice.  Good repartee between Ginny and Bill.  I enjoyed the premonition of Umbridge with Tonks!  Thanks for the story!  Brad.
Wednesday 1st June 2005 00:24Lingering Doubt (Author Response)
Thanks, Brad!
This was mostly me exploring a few ideas and throwing in a few things to amuse myself (like the Umbridge thing...and revisiting Dumbledore's canon love for socks. ;).