Authors: - A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P R S T V W X Y Z

Reviews For The Prefect by Bella

Majyk
Sunday 18th April 2010 08:44
The Prefect
I almost wish you had continued this story
gymnastgal19
Wednesday 20th August 2008 21:14
The Prefect
huh interesting
majolie
Thursday 3rd January 2008 12:56
The Prefect
Excellent. I'm going to have to read all your fics now.
bookish327
Sunday 30th December 2007 09:45
The Prefect
Excellent story! I love how you write Ginny; she's so feisty, funny, and smart. (The threat to bite the twins, and the "buggering walruses" were especially hilarious.) She's very true to the books, as are the other characters. I loved the stuff about Ron's gleefully broadcasting Ginny's big news, his and Hermione's bickering, and especially Ginny's talk with Bill. His approval of Ginny and Harry being a couple one day, and his asking about a bet when Ron and Hermione would kiss were great touches. Also, Harry helping Ginny by distracting Mrs. Weasley about Hermione carrying the cake was sweet. Ginny falling off her chair, and her exclamation when the candle went out were also fun touches.

Ginny's prefect gift also made sense concerning giving her a special edge in making the Quidditch team as a regular player. Also, a good parallel to Ron: having a new broom helped him get a regular spot on the team, too. It's fun when the fic's plot points support the book's. One last thing: I loved the conversation about Ginny continuing her nighttime kitchen raids, even now that she was a prefect. This kind of conversation between Ginny and Harry is great because it reminds both the reader and Harry that Ginny is very mischievous and fun. (It would be easy for some to take her for granted as a background character, instead of appreciating all of her special humor and cleverness.)

Wonderful premise, Ginny being made a prefect, and all of the teasing that would result from that, and then you took that very good idea and made it a great story.
chiantiqueen
Thursday 20th December 2007 08:49
The Prefect
Really enjoyed reading this one, great little story.
pyromain
Sunday 24th June 2007 14:27
The Prefect
I really liked the story, it's a good thing you warned that it was a one shot because else i would be demanding a sequel or the next chapter.
lilydust
Tuesday 20th February 2007 22:58
The Prefect
i thought it was great... darn it i got hooked
Felix Felicis
Friday 15th December 2006 17:27
The Prefect
Great story. Short but neat. I love Ginny's continued reaction to being a Prefect, so much fun! The way you had Harry and Ginny meet in the dead of night was sweet. I only wish there would have been some more talk-time between them. They're so well matched when it comes to talking and sharing their heart and soul.

The warning about this just being a one-shot makes sense. I wish there was more but it's just as much fun to make up the rest in my imagination!
hjdevnull
Thursday 2nd March 2006 12:24
The Prefect
Oh, this is so good. I love that you don't show them getting together, but rather just a hint of things to come. You also have an excellent Ginny voice, and your dialogue in this story is just as good as it is in all your other stories.

Hope your school year is going well, and I can't wait for you to get some time to write some more stuff.
green_eyez
Thursday 24th November 2005 16:28
The Prefect

fine since this a one-shot i suppose i should review...

i love it...

good enough? lol no but really its awesome!! be sure to write more awesome fics sooon!

 

ridgeback77
Friday 30th September 2005 15:23
The Prefect
Nice one shot.  I enjoyed reading it.
mbwun5
Saturday 9th July 2005 10:10
The Prefect

You're right the last line does sound like you are setting this up to be a multi-chapter fic, but it doesn't matter.  This is a wonderful story, able to stand on it's own. 

I really liked the line about Fred and George being unbearable.  It really caught me by surprise and I laughed out loud.  I loved that it popped into Ginny's head just after how bad Mrs. Weasley was going to be.

Your interactions between Harry and Ginny were really done well.  You kept them short, but meaningful.  They felt right and rang true.  Sometimes people force Harry and Ginny, but you really found the right pace for this fic.  Good job.

I just wanted to reiterate how much I liked this fic.  Great job, it's wonderful.

p0tterfan
Thursday 16th June 2005 22:37
The Prefect
Definitely a fun shot .... but by ending it that way ... it totally seems like a prologue ... or atleast the first chapter of a multi chaptered story :)

Keep up the good work!  
Megan SQ
Thursday 16th June 2005 00:40
The Prefect
Great writing! Even without much of a plot, you kept me entertained from start to finish.
nixtear
Wednesday 15th June 2005 20:09
The Prefect
levotatingT
Wednesday 15th June 2005 19:28
The Prefect

That is really good.  It does seem to be as if you are going to continue.  I know you said in the beginning you weren't going to keep going but would begging help??????

great job, keep writing, and Plez write back

levotatingT

h2o
Wednesday 15th June 2005 12:57
The Prefect

Noo! You can't make this a one-shot, it's way too good for that! This is one of the best fics I've read in a very long time, I love it to pieces  Great writing and you just stayed in canon so well that I thought "This could actually happen in HBP!" I beg you to consider making a sequel, even if it's just another one-shot!

//Kev

Black_White_And_Grey
Wednesday 15th June 2005 10:15
The Prefect
I've only skimmed this thing but I don't need to process every word to realize what a wonderful, whimsical, whitty/clever piece of work this has turned out to be. :) I love it so much, and it could convert anyone to the H/G stuff that is ever-popular on this site. ;D Brilliant. I give in a 9, at very least. Too funny. :D
hermionegreen
Wednesday 15th June 2005 07:05
The Prefect

Awesome story!!! I for one would have liked to see them kiss ... perhaps in one of your other stories?  I'm off to go see....

 

'Mione

critmo
Wednesday 15th June 2005 02:42
The Prefect
Very nice, very funny - and even if you've made it clear that this is a ONE-SHOT, I can't help begging for more!
Laurel Carmer
Tuesday 14th June 2005 18:41
The Prefect
Aww... how very cute and sweet.  I loved it.  God bless plot bunnies.
Mangykneazle
Tuesday 14th June 2005 17:21
The Prefect

This story is utterly perfect.  I am enthralled by your development of Ginny as an independent person and as a young woman under the mixed expectations of her family as well as her own.  Ginny's gift to Harry and her demand were a stroke of genius.

Your characterisation of Harry was extremely well done, too.  He is pained by his experiences, but he's able to move onward.  Certainly, this is one of the best fics I've read in a while.

Musings
Tuesday 14th June 2005 16:24
The Prefect

Argh!!  Oh, this just killed me...

He moved half an inch towards her, still staring down into her eyes, and she in turn moved a full inch. He lowered his head – and –

-they were plunged into complete and utter darkness.

And now we have to suffer... ; )  Anyhow, thank you for this wonderful little one shot.  I was in need of some H/G fluffy goodness and this more than fulfilled my craving!

Now if I could just have some of that cake as well... ; )

Antonia East
Tuesday 14th June 2005 14:07
The Prefect
I think it worked nicely on its own.  Brilliant Ginny pov and some hilarious moments- buggering walruses, Fred and George in general ...

SillyGillie
Tuesday 14th June 2005 14:06
The Prefect
Awesome job! I loved it! I really wish you were writing a sequel! That stinks!
Spark Soliton
Tuesday 14th June 2005 13:54
The Prefect

      Nooooo - how can this possibly be a one-shot!!!!!! And oh the CRUELTY of not even letting them share a single kiss!!!

On a more positive note, after the above rant, this was brilliant writing, loved the dialogue and I very much enjoyed that you wrote it in Ginny's POV, it made for a refreshing change!!!! The "Ginny Sandwich" sent me into gales of laughter, well the whole reaction to Ginny Prefect badge made laugh !

So a full round of  - lovely, wonderful little story!!! The only bad thing I can say about it is that it needs another chapter!!! Perhaps an epilogue, set a couple of years in the future, with Ginny looking back???

Hank
Tuesday 14th June 2005 13:06
The Prefect
Nice story - too bad you're not going to keep going.  I like how you brought them almost there and backed off.  Of course, now you've gone and given us a cliff-hanger with no ending...  I hate it when that happens.  Your characterization of the Weasleys felt right on target.  Harry and Hermione felt right, too.  All-in-all, it's a beautiful little story.
Kelleypen
Tuesday 14th June 2005 13:03
The Prefect
This really begs for a part two.  Begs? Screams!  You can join BaF in her court--She's the queen of delayed gratification. Beautifully done.