gymnastgal19
Sunday 21st October 2007 15:40 | Half-Blood Prince Drabbles |
| wow! that's intense! |
Wooster
Thursday 29th June 2006 07:27 | Half-Blood Prince Drabbles |
| Whoa. Now that was really different...and really cool! I never even thought about that... |
| Thursday 29th June 2006 23:38 | Half-Blood Prince Drabbles (Author Response) |
| Thank you! This is what comes from reading Half-Blood Prince too many times in one month - the teeniest, tiniest things stick in your head ... |
Delani
Wednesday 5th October 2005 20:43 | Half-Blood Prince Drabbles |
How do you do this? I'm so torn now that I can't decide which is more well-written and yet still so impeccable right! Well done, and now I'm off to see if you have other works... |
| Thursday 6th October 2005 18:43 | Half-Blood Prince Drabbles (Author Response) |
| Gosh! Thanks for your reviews, glad you liked them. I love drabbles because sometimes it doesn't take very long to say what you want to say, but nevertheless, it has to be said! |
MercuryBlue
Wednesday 5th October 2005 17:56 | Half-Blood Prince Drabbles |
Lemme get this straight. You're saying Slughorn retired because
Voldemort killed Lily? Minor continuity error here. Snape had been
teaching for 'fourteen years' as of September Harry's fifth year. Ergo,
he was on staff for two months before Lily died. Ergo, Slughorn retired
two to four months before Lily died. Ergo, there was no connection
between the two events. You might want to fix that.
|
| Wednesday 5th October 2005 18:23 | Half-Blood Prince Drabbles (Author Response) |
Thanks for reviewing. That's a very precise interpretation. Two months is enough leeway in the approximation of 14 years that they could be connected. Anyway, the spirit of the story is that Slughorn's judgement about a student had been so wrong - and he certainly knew Voldemort was a rotten egg before Lily died. |
