Authors: - A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P R S T V W X Y Z

Reviews For The Sins of the Fathers by parakletos

lwj2
Sunday 20th April 2014 19:49
The Sins of the Fathers
You've an interesting premise here; I'm not at all sure why Harry is entering Hogwarts so late. Is it possible to give some background in future chapters?

I'm looking forward with a great deal of anticipation to discovering where you go with this; thanks for writing and sharing your story.
Starscape91
Tuesday 19th January 2010 22:12
The Sins of the Fathers
Great story! I can't wait to read more!
Friday 26th March 2010 13:24The Sins of the Fathers (Author Response)
not at this site you won't, sorry.
ninkenate
Saturday 13th June 2009 12:54
The Sins of the Fathers
This is a very interesting chapter. Harry keeps surprising me with his actions. I'm not sure if Tonks still has a larger role to play or not but I find it interesting the direction you are going in so far. I think the next meeting between Harry and the Weasleys, whether it be one or one or him to many more, should be enlightening. Ginny and Harry appear to be attracted to each other but also seem to be fighting that attraction, even if subconsciously. I really like what you have written so far and look forward to the next surprises you have in store for us.
potternut190
Tuesday 21st April 2009 18:33
The Sins of the Fathers
Where might your interesting fic be headed?
Wednesday 22nd April 2009 00:43The Sins of the Fathers (Author Response)
Metafic as per my profile.
The Pharaoh
Sunday 19th April 2009 01:46
The Sins of the Fathers
So why is Ginny in Harry's and Ron's year? Why are the Weasleys so pureblood-aristocratic? Is that another fanfic cliché? And why is there a graffitied tunnel surrounding the steam-engine train instead of country scenery? Are you trying to make this a complete opposite of canon? I'm not critisizing, honestly, I'm just genuinely curious. My only critisism of this chapter is that the line, "I expect that you spent a lot of time with Julie, your girlfriend." sounds forced and is phrased awkwardly besides. Dean saying they broke up sufficiently shows that Julie was his girlfriend, and regardless of that, the words "your girlfriend" shouldn't be tacked on and left to dangle awkwardly at the end of the sentence.
I found Snape to be accurately portrayed insofar as I can judge, his AU position below Harry notwithstanding. His sarcasm and thinly veiled manner of speaking seem fitting of his personality, and his reaction to the Sorting makes sense. Snape's potential reaction to having Harry in Slytherin is ambiguous. On the one hand he's a constant reminder of his father, who he hated, but on the other hand he's also a reminder of Lily, who he liked, and Snape could see Harry being in Slytherin as a triumph over James and the other marauders. This is all ignoring canon, based solely on what you've written. With DH in the picture, I'm inclined to lean toward his reminder of Lily being a bad thing, and thus a dreaded torment for Snape. Again, I don't know how much you're trying to repel from canon, this is just my personal take on it. I hope it helps.
Sunday 19th April 2009 13:59The Sins of the Fathers (Author Response)
So why is Ginny in Harry's and Ron's year?



I answered this is review response below.


Why are the Weasleys so pureblood-aristocratic? Is that another fanfic cliché?


Yes.


And why is there a graffitied tunnel surrounding the steam-engine train instead of country scenery? Are you trying to make this a complete opposite of canon? I'm not critisizing, honestly, I'm just genuinely curious.


I travelled in and out of Kings Cross for 18 months. The first part of the journey is urban and not very pretty.


My only critisism of this chapter is that the line, "I expect that you spent a lot of time with Julie, your girlfriend." sounds forced and is phrased awkwardly besides. Dean saying they broke up sufficiently shows that Julie was his girlfriend, and regardless of that, the words "your girlfriend" shouldn't be tacked on and left to dangle awkwardly at the end of the sentence.


Day to day speech is never grammatically corrrect. Ever. I've managed to beat this out of my betas although its taken a while :p


I found Snape to be accurately portrayed insofar as I can judge, his AU position below Harry notwithstanding. His sarcasm and thinly veiled manner of speaking seem fitting of his personality, and his reaction to the Sorting makes sense. Snape's potential reaction to having Harry in Slytherin is ambiguous. On the one hand he's a constant reminder of his father, who he hated, but on the other hand he's also a reminder of Lily, who he liked, and Snape could see Harry being in Slytherin as a triumph over James and the other marauders. This is all ignoring canon, based solely on what you've written. With DH in the picture, I'm inclined to lean toward his reminder of Lily being a bad thing, and thus a dreaded torment for Snape. Again, I don't know how much you're trying to repel from canon, this is just my personal take on it. I hope it helps.


Well, here I've failed then, because I was trying not to write canon Snape.I'd suggest that you ignore canon when assessing the impact of Lily's eyes. A longer infatuation is clearly shown in the narrative, so go back and read again.

I'm always happy when people take time to leave a well written review, but the danger with a story that is published chapter by chapter is that people want answers immediately and they are not going to get them. There are also aspects of every story that are a given. You just have to accept them (me included). This is a fanfic cliché rewrite. As the story summary says In 1879, to repay a debt of honour, Cyriac Weasley promises the hand of the next Weasley girl to be born to the eldest male heir of the Potter family. A reworking of many once-original ideas that have now become clichés in the world of fanfic. This features Slytherin (and super!)Harry, a betrothal contract, redeemed (?) Bella and, of course, Ginny.

harry_ginnyfan
Saturday 18th April 2009 06:52
The Sins of the Fathers
Good chapter, but slytherin? Please write another chapter soon
freshwater
Friday 17th April 2009 10:05
The Sins of the Fathers
Wow.

The prologue and ch. 1 were intriguing....but this chapter has taken things to a whole new level. LOVE the interactions of Harry with his peers and Snape. He's obnoxious in a way that I love to hate and I am looking forward to his learning some better manners than those of pureblood society.

I like Ginny so far, but I am expecting some fireworks from her later in the story ---as befits any spunky heroine of a 19th century romance novel. **wink**smile** I'm looking forward for your self-posessed Mr.Potter being discomfitted a bit by his betrothed.

And the deadline for an engagement is 10 days?!? Why did Black waste 20 days of the grace period? Did he just want to turn the pressure on for Harry?
memasuzy
Thursday 16th April 2009 14:45
The Sins of the Fathers
I started reading this after realizing you had put some of your earlier work for now (I do hope you will go back to it eventually!).

This is a very interesting twist on things! Aunt Bella - hmm. . . ; Slytherin Harry, and Malfoy in Ravenclaw!

I always enjoyed reading 19th century romance and like the way the majical marrage contract is forcing Harry & Ginny to react to eachother within those constraints. One question though: You mention what happens if Harry chooses to forfet the contract - but what would happen if Ginny refused - if she didn\'t want to marry a Slytherin?
aharkins
Wednesday 15th April 2009 12:52
The Sins of the Fathers
I'm loving this. Everyone's out of character but you've done it in such an interesting way that I just have to keep reading. Hope you'll update soon.

honourary_weasley
Wednesday 15th April 2009 07:58
The Sins of the Fathers
"As I appear to have been blessed with those whose families have pursued the purity at the expense of a viable gene pool, I will spell things out for you."

Classic Snape! Fantastic - I'm really rather intrigued as to where exactly this is going. Hopefully next chapter we'll get a few more details as to what exactly Harry has been up to the past few years instead of being at Hogwarts.
zorica
Wednesday 15th April 2009 00:06
The Sins of the Fathers
Loving this. Please keep it up. Thanks for sharing your hard work.
Jacynthe
Tuesday 14th April 2009 21:29
The Sins of the Fathers
So glad to see that you are writing again. Not sure where you are going with it, since you seem to have ruled out the obvious plot element of conflict between Harry and a Ginny understandably miffed at the way in which her life has been decided for her. (It's easy to see why, for this audience, passive!Ginny is harder to swallow than spoiled-prince!Harry -- evil!Ginny, as you will recall from your own past work, goes over a treat...) I agree with some of your other reviewers that there seem to be rather a lot of unexplained elements in these first few chapters, but have no doubt that you know where you are going, and will presently explain it to the rest of us. Writing is hard. Hang in there !
Patches
Tuesday 14th April 2009 02:35
The Sins of the Fathers
This is excellent. I like the beginning when Harry and Tonks were bantering back and forth. It is too bad in a way that Tonks has fallen in love with Harry. Harry isn't free to choose who he wants and Tonks is not in line to be his. I really liked the reaction Harry and Ginny had to each other during their brief encounter when Ginny arrived at the train. They are drawn to each other. That tells me that there is more to this than an old man's greed in the past. I hope it means that Harry and Ginny are destined to be together. Ron, of course is acting like an idiot. I'm glad Harry declared himself. It was unusual for him to lick Ginny's fingers. I'm glad that Ginny feels something when she looks at Harry. I'm not surprised that the Hat put Harry in Slytherin. It wanted to in cannon. This story can't run too smoothly. There has to be some bumps in the road. I really look forward to how you handle this. thanks so much for writing. p
Patches
Tuesday 14th April 2009 02:34
The Sins of the Fathers
This is excellent. I like the beginning when Harry and Tonks were bantering back and forth. It is too bad in a way that Tonks has fallen in love with Harry. Harry isn't free to choose who he wants and Tonks is not in line to be his. I really liked the reaction Harry and Ginny had to each other during their brief encounter when Ginny arrived at the train. They are drawn to each other. That tells me that there is more to this than an old man's greed in the past. I hope it means that Harry and Ginny are destined to be together. Ron, of course is acting like an idiot. I'm glad Harry declared himself. It was unusual for him to lick Ginny's fingers. I'm glad that Ginny feels something when she looks at Harry. I'm not surprised that the Hat put Harry in Slytherin. It wanted to in cannon. This story can't run too smoothly. There has to be some bumps in the road. I really look forward to how you handle this. thanks so much for writing. p
anniep
Monday 13th April 2009 16:59
The Sins of the Fathers
The ways you’ve turned the characterizations sideways are so much fun to read! Ron obsessed with Harry Potter for years, Draco as a quiet Ravenclaw, an obsequious Severus—they all made me smile. Many changes can be traced to the absence of Harry in their lives, but the additional tweaks sound like an author having fun with his story.

I’m a bit confused about the student years. Hogwarts was closed the previous year due to the war, but why are Ron and Ginny both 7th years? The best scenario I can come up with to answer that would be if last year Ginny was home-schooled and Ron was off fighting with the Order.

Contrary to what Sirius said, it seems that Mrs Weasley does know about the marriage contract. Why else would she and Arthur exchange worried glances when the topic of Harry going to Hogwarts came up or why would she refuse to talk about Ginny’s boy problems with her daughter? If she does know, then why would that information be withheld from Ginny? (Of course, why was it withheld from Harry too?)

Harry’s first meeting with Ginny (as himself) didn’t go as I’d expected. It took a second reading of this chapter before it occurred to me that maybe he was following a prescribed format for meeting his betrothed. Earlier, in the compartment with Tonks, Harry was very nervous that he “had to introduce himself and make his intentions clear”. The coupling of those two actions in his ruminations, plus the fact that it pleased Ginny rather than made her laugh or slap him, sounds like he had to do things a certain way in order to fulfill the demands of the magic. Am I reading too much into your words?
magical princess
Monday 13th April 2009 16:16
The Sins of the Fathers
I'm really liking this story and your writing style just not the rate of updates. I love how you have melded all the cliches about this type of fanfiction story together to create something unique that still makes me want to read it. I really can't wait to read the next chapter. I hope you can update sooner.
zeta_one
Monday 13th April 2009 12:26
The Sins of the Fathers
Oh how I love a thinking Harry instead of the all heart Harry. This story has grab my attention. Thanks for sharing.
DukeBrymin
Monday 13th April 2009 08:25
The Sins of the Fathers
So, in your responses to reviews, you mention that Hogwarts was closed last year. But, if everyone missed last year, wouldn't Ginny have missed too, therefore only be in sixth year while Harry's in seventh?

Tonks, carrying a torch for Harry, eh? Interesting sub-plot there.

Ginny, Head Girl? I can certainly understand her grades, what with not being able to date or anything, but Hermione is in the same year, for some reason, so maybe it was a coin flip?

A nice Draco, in Ravenclaw, no less. Interesting, and perfectly in line with your turning of canon characterization upside-down. And Harry's supercilious attitude towards Snape was rather fascinating. I don't like stuckup!Harry, but I think he's using his "pure-blood" training not to be better than anyone, but rather to treat people in the way he thinks they deserve.

I love this line: ". . .into a post-pumpkin pasty ennui."

Some minor nits to pick:

"Perhaps this year would be different, she thought." This should be in present tense--"Perhaps this year will be different, she thought."

". . .would free her from its affects." Affect is always a verb, you want "effects" in this case.

". . .make it easier to play court to Ginevra. . ." Shouldn't that be "pay court"?

And one last plaudit: I love that Harry just sees the Sorting as a way to tweak Dumbledore.

Great chapter! Hope your health issues don't interfere too much with your life, and that you can continue to write.
Thanks!
Saturday 18th April 2009 17:48The Sins of the Fathers (Author Response)
So, in your responses to reviews, you mention that Hogwarts was closed last year. But, if everyone missed last year, wouldn't Ginny have missed too, therefore only be in sixth year while Harry's in seventh?


To clarify: this year would have been Ginny's 7th. The missed year means different things for different people. Ginny and Hermione, safe from the war carried on studying. Ron and other couldn't be bothered. So there are essentially 2 7th years and the student are organised according to academic criteria. Thus Ron will not be in the same class as Ginny.

Ginny, Head Girl? I can certainly understand her grades, what with not being able to date or anything, but Hermione is in the same year, for some reason, so maybe it was a coin flip?


Ginny gets it as a more rounded individual.

Some minor nits to pick:

"Perhaps this year would be different, she thought." This should be in present tense--"Perhaps this year will be different, she thought."

". . .would free her from its affects." Affect is always a verb, you want "effects" in this case.

". . .make it easier to play court to Ginevra. . ." Shouldn't that be "pay court"?


Thanks (?) for pointing those out. I've passed it on to the beta team with instructions for them to be beaten with a wet kipper.


Great chapter! Hope your health issues don't interfere too much with your life, and that you can continue to write.
Thanks!


I hope so too.

Thanks for reviewing.
ionik27
Monday 13th April 2009 07:09
The Sins of the Fathers
hey, parakletos... forgot to add something very important: hope you're well and healthy and fit to write this story as fast as magicaly possible... we certainly wish you are!
Lots of hugs and kisses
aimless`
Monday 13th April 2009 05:43
The Sins of the Fathers
I surely like this fic, but i'd prefer to read it after(if) it finished.

Really fun to see Harry so out of character we used to .
---

bookworm08, never heard of woman aproaching a man in this way . But anyway, I guess the thing here is that Ginny never had a romantic relationship (as of her predicament), so she quite welcomed the moment when someone finally come to her with obvious intent...
Saturday 18th April 2009 17:24The Sins of the Fathers (Author Response)
Well I'd prefer it to be finished too. I wrote the outline for this in 2007.

Thanks for reviewing.
bookworm08
Monday 13th April 2009 05:13
The Sins of the Fathers
I must admit that while I am fascinated by your story, I am to some extent disgusted. I have been forced to grow accustomed to some measure of sexism within fanfiction, however here it is displayed unusually blatantly.

My major problem is the fact that Ginny might be flattered by a perfect (though attractive) stranger calling her his, and explaining his actions to her brother instead of to her. This not only portrays Ginny as an airhead concerned only with finding a rich and attractive husband, but as an object of property, belonging to both her brother and Harry.

While in contract-marriage fics, some amount of this is expected, it would be more politically correct if sexism was confined to the actions of the irresponsible/archaic men who formed the contract, not within the interaction of the couple in question.

If a man was approached by a woman who:

"took the initiative and reached down to hold [his] left hand in [hers]. Raising it up, [she] bent forward whilst still maintaining eye contact with [him]. [She] then slowly spread the fingers apart and licked gently on the web between [his] middle and ring fingers with the tip of [her] tongue"

If she then explained that no impropriety had been committed but that she was merely claiming what was hers, it would be an exchange that would not belong within a Teens rated fic, and which would be highly insulting in any other context.

I protest that it is just as insulting to a woman who is the subject of such an exchange, even if disguised under the name of romance.

I hope I will not be so disgusted again.
Monday 13th April 2009 10:31The Sins of the Fathers (Author Response)
I must admit that while I am fascinated by your story, I am to some extent disgusted. I have been forced to grow accustomed to some measure of sexism within fanfiction, however here it is displayed unusually blatantly.

My major problem is the fact that Ginny might be flattered by a perfect (though attractive) stranger calling her his, and explaining his actions to her brother instead of to her. This not only portrays Ginny as an airhead concerned only with finding a rich and attractive husband, but as an object of property, belonging to both her brother and Harry.

While in contract-marriage fics, some amount of this is expected, it would be more politically correct if sexism was confined to the actions of the irresponsible/archaic men who formed the contract, not within the interaction of the couple in question.

If a man was approached by a woman who:

"took the initiative and reached down to hold [his] left hand in [hers]. Raising it up, [she] bent forward whilst still maintaining eye contact with [him]. [She] then slowly spread the fingers apart and licked gently on the web between [his] middle and ring fingers with the tip of [her] tongue"

If she then explained that no impropriety had been committed but that she was merely claiming what was hers, it would be an exchange that would not belong within a Teens rated fic, and which would be highly insulting in any other context.

I protest that it is just as insulting to a woman who is the subject of such an exchange, even if disguised under the name of romance.

I hope I will not be so disgusted again.


Ok, you'd better stop reading now.

Are you familiar with the concept of a Peace Cow? That is what Ginny is and is magically constrained to behave that way. You will also find it uncomfortable when Harry makes comments about Dumbledore's sexuality.

In general, I would suggest that learning to accept that characters are often (highly) flawed. This Harry has few, if any, social skills and what he does have are the product of the lothario Sirius Black ( who will bed anything that bends over long enough) and his Aunt who sees nothing wrong with the marriage arrangement.

Ultimately, you can decided to read other fics or complain to the Admins regarding the rating of this fic.